TESTS

   1 Default settings, 5000 playouts.
   2 Opponent: gnugo --mode gtp --chinese-rules --capture-all-dead --level 10
   3 GNUGo 3.7.12
   4
   5 Template:
   6 ../../gogui-1.1.10/bin/gogui-twogtp -black  'gnugo --mode gtp --chinese-rules --capture-all-dead --level 10' -white './zzgo-77d2d games=5000,policy=ucb1amaf,playout=moggy' -alternate -auto -verbose -size 9 -komi 7.5 -games 100 -sgffile f1-77d2d
   7 for i in *.dat; do ../../gogui-1.1.10/bin/gogui-twogtp -force -analyze $i; done
   8
   9 ead8e   ucb1amaf        16.5% (+-4.5%)
  10
  11 b2185   ucb1amaf        50% (+-6%)
  12
  13 75fff   ucb1amaf        49% (+-4%)
  14
  15 c5bea   ucb1amaf        42.5% (+-2.5%)
  16
  17 95bf3   ucb1amaf        25.2% (+-4%)
  18
  19 c7249   ucb1amaf        34.2% (+-4.8%)
  20
  21 9367d   ucb1amaf        37% (+-8%)
  22
  23 ce540   ucb1amaf*       42% (+-2%)      selfatarirate=0
  24 ce540   ucb1amaf        43% (+-2%)
  25
  26 62592   ucb1amaf*       47% (+-2.5%)    selfatarirate=0
  27 62592   ucb1amaf        44% (+-2.5%)
  28 62592   ucb1amaf*#      45.2% (+-2.5%)  selfatarirate=0,rave_prior
  29 62592   ucb1amaf#       47.5% (+-2.5%)  rave_prior
  30
  31 1a1eb   ucb1            15% (+-2%)      selfatarirate=0:capturerate=0:lcapturerate=0
  32
  33 6e22f   ucb1amaf        49.5% (+-2.5%)
  34 6e22f   ucb1amaf*0      48% (+-2.5%)    rave_equiv=6000
  35 6e22f   ucb1amaf*1      49% (+-2.5%)    rave_equiv=500
  36 6e22f   ucb1amaf#       43.2% (+-2.5%)  explore_p=0
  37 6e22f   ucb1amaf#*0     45.8% (+-2.5%)  explore_p=0,rave_equiv=6000
  38 6e22f   ucb1amaf#*1     48.8% (+-2.5%)  explore_p=0,rave_equiv=500
  39 6e22f   ucb1amaf#0      49.5% (+-2.5%)  explore_p=0.01
  40 6e22f   ucb1amaf#1      24.8% (+-2.5%)  explore_p=0.5
  41 6e22f   19x19 ucb1amaf  0%
  42 6e22f   19x19 ucb1amaf* 0%      explore_p=0.01,rave_equiv=100
  43
  44 88fe2   ucb1amaf        50.8% (+-2.5%)
  45 88fe2   ucb1amaf*       49.5% (+-2.5%)  selfatarirate=0
  46
  47 04b7b   ucb1amaf        60.5% (+-2.4%)
  48 04b7b   ucb1amaf*       60.2% (+-2.4%)  selfatarirate=0
  49 04b7b   ucb1amaf%1      58.5% (+-2.5%)  rate=75
  50 04b7b   ucb1amaf%2      60.8% (+-2.4%)  rate=100
  51 04b7b   ucb1amaf#       54.5% (+-2.5%)  explore_p=0
  52 04b7b   ucb1amaf^       63.5% (+-2.4%)  threads=2
  53 04b7b   ucb1amaf+       71.2% (+-2.3%)  games=10000
  54 04b7b   ucb1amaf!       79.5% (+-2%)    playout_amaf
  55 04b7b   ucb1amaf!&      46% (+-2.5%)    playout_amaf,patternrate=0
  56
  57 82790   ucb1amaf        54.1% (+-2.9%)
  58 82790   ucb1amaf!       79% (+-2.9%)    playout_amaf
  59
  60 129bb   ucb1amaf        64.5% (+-2.4%)
  61 129bb   ucb1amaf!       77.2% (+-2.1%)  playout_amaf
  62
  63 <playout_amaf_nakade on by default>
  64
  65 605dd   ucb1amaf        56.2% (+-2.5%)
  66 605dd   ucb1amaf!       63.5% (+-2.4%)  playout_amaf
  67
  68 <unknown playout_amaf regression>
  69
  70 c031a   ucb1amaf        52.5% (+-4.2%)
  71 c031a   ucb1amaf!       63.4% (+-4.2%)  playout_amaf
  72
  73 87b9e   ucb1amaf        53.7% (+-2.1%)
  74 87b9e   ucb1amaf#1      59.5% (+-1.7%)  explore_p_rave=0
  75 87b9e   ucb1amaf#2      59.1% (+-1.7%)  explore_p=0.01,explore_p_rave=0.01
  76 87b9e   ucb1amaf%       56.6% (+-2%)    local_assess
  77 87b9e   ucb1amaf*       19% (+-1.3%)    patternrate=0
  78 87b9e   ucb1amaf!$      62.8% (+-2.4%)  playout_amaf,rave_equiv=500
  79 87b9e   ucb1amaf!#1     62.8% (+-1.7%)  playout_amaf,explore_p=0.01,explore_p_rave=0.01
  80 87b9e   ucb1amaf!#2     61.6% (+-1.7%)  playout_amaf,explore_p_rave=0.01
  81 87b9e   ucb1amaf!&      61.8% (+-2.4%)  playout_amaf,eqex=25
  82 87b9e   ucb1amaf!       61.4% (+-2.1%)  playout_amaf
  83
  84 <playout_amaf is now default>
  85
  86 093e7   ucb1amaf        60.5% (+-2.4%)
  87 093e7   ucb1amaf!       58.8% (+-2.5%)  plaout_amaf=0
  88 093e7   ucb1amaf%       60.8% (+-2.4%)  ladders=0
  89
  90 <playout_amaf_nakade partially off>
  91
  92 635a3   ucb1amaf        65% (+-2.4%)
  93 635a3   ucb1amaf        63% (+-2.4%)    explore_p_rave=0.01
  94
  95 <playout_amaf_nakade off by default>
  96
  97 eac23   ucb1amaf        77.4% (+-1.5%)
  98 eac23   ucb1amaf#       76.6% (+-1.5%)  explore_p_rave=0.01
  99 eac23   ucb1amaf!       74.3% (+-1.5%)  check_nakade=0
 100 eac23   ucb1amaf!#      75.5% (+-1.6%)  check_nakade=0,explore_p_rave=0.01
 101 eac23   ucb1amaf!#*     75% (+-1.5%)    check_nakade=0,explore_p_rave=0.01,explore_p=0.01
 102
 103 <explore_p_rave=0.01>
 104
 105 229b9   ucb1amaf 2k     65.5% (+-2.4%)
 106 229b9   ucb1amaf 5k     77.5% (+-2.1%)
 107 229b9   ucb1amaf 20k    83.8% (+-1.7%)
 108 229b9   ucb1amaf 50k    90% (+-1.5%)
 109 229b9   ucb1amaf! 2k    37.8% (+-2.4%)  playout_amaf=0
 110 229b9   ucb1amaf! 5k    59% (+-2.5%)    playout_amaf=0
 111 229b9   ucb1amaf! 20k   79% (+-2%)      playout_amaf=0
 112 229b9   ucb1amaf! 50k   83.5% (+-1.9%)  playout_amaf=0
 113 229b9   ucb1amaf% 5k    77.2% (+-2.1%)  ladders=0
 114 229b9   ucb1amaf*# 5k   74.9% (+-2.2%)  explore_p=0.005,explore_p_rave=0.005
 115
 116 self-play:
 117 229b9   ucb1amaf km5.5  B+57.5% (+-2.5%)
 118 229b9   ucb1amaf km7.5  B+48.8% (+-2.5%)
 119
 120 2d54a   ucb1amaf        72.2% (+-2.2%)
 121
 122 8ac8a   ucb1amaf        77% (+-2.1%)
 123 8ac8a   ucb1amaf@       77% (+-2.1%)    ladder catcher atari check disabled
 124 8ac8a   ucb1amaf 50k    93.5% (+-1.2%)
 125
 126
 127 fccfe   ucb1amaf        78% (+-2.1%)
 128 fccfe   ucb1amaf#       78.5% (+-2.1%)  rave_prior=0
 129 fccfe   ucb1amaf*0      76% (+-2.1%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=50
 130 fccfe   ucb1amaf*0!     78.5% (+-2.1%)  playout_amaf_cutoff=50,playout_amaf_nakade=1
 131 fccfe   ucb1amaf*1      79.8% (+-2%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=75
 132 fccfe   ucb1amaf*1!     74% (+-2.2%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=75,playout_amaf_nakade=1
 133 fccfe   ucb1amaf*2      76.7% (+-2.1%)  playout_amaf_cutoff=85
 134 fccfe   ucb1amaf*2!     77% (+-2.1%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=85,playout_amaf_nakade=1
 135 fccfe   ucb1amaf*3      72% (+-2.2%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=90
 136 fccfe   ucb1amaf*3!     73% (+-2.2%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=90,playout_amaf_nakade=1
 137 fccfe   ucb1amaf*3      72% (+-2.2%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=90
 138 fccfe   ucb1amaf*3!     73% (+-2.2%)    playout_amaf_cutoff=90,playout_amaf_nakade=1
 139
 140 Threading test:
 141 fccfe   ucb1amaf        78% (+-2.1%)
 142 fccfe   ucb1amaf 10k    79.8% (+-2%)
 143 fccfe   ucb1amaf t=2    75.5% (+-2.2%)
 144 569d7   ucb1amaf t=2    82.9% (+-1.9%)
 145
 146
 147 <Multiple board sizes from now on>
 148
 149 Fillboard investigations (only 4-lib fillboard yet):
 150
 151 569d7   9ucb1amaf!      81.2% (+-2%)    fillboardtries=10
 152 569d7   9ucb1amaf 50k   90% (+-1.5%)
 153 569d7   9ucb1amaf! 50k  90.8% (+-1.4%)  fillboardtries=10
 154
 155 ce382   13ucb1amaf      51.8% (+-2.5%)
 156 ce382   13ucb1amaf 50k  79.6% (+-2.6%)
 157 569d7   13ucb1amaf!     47% (+-2.5%)    fillboardtries=10
 158 569d7   13ucb1amaf! 50k 82.8% (+-2.4%)  fillboardtries=10
 159
 160
 161 <many optimizations>
 162
 163 4181b   9ucb1amaf       76% (+-2.4%)
 164 4181b   13ucb1amaf      47.8% (+-2.5%)
 165 4181b   19ucb1amaf      1.6% (+-0.9%)
 166 4181b   19ucb1amaf!     1% (+-0.7%)     fillboardtries=10
 167
 168
 169 0965e   9ucb1amaf       77.5% (+-2.1%)
 170 0965e   9ucb1amaf#      9.5% (+-1.5%)   sylvain_rave=0
 171 0965e   9ucb1amaf&      79% (+-2.1%)    self-atari protection turned off for single-stone groups
 172
 173 0965e   13ucb1amaf      45.2% (+-2.5%)
 174 0965e   13ucb1amaf&     52.2% (+-2.5%)  self-atari protection turned off for single-stone groups
 175
 176 <permit snapbacks>
 177
 178 234b3   9ucb1amaf       77.2% (+-2.1%)
 179 234b3   13ucb1amaf      47% (+-2.5%)
 180
 181
 182 <add pattern2>
 183
 184 035fc   9ucb1amaf       70.5% (+-2.3%)
 185 035fc   9ucb1amaf#      79.8% (+-2%)    pattern2=0
 186
 187 <add 2-liberty>
 188
 189 74b71   9ucb1amaf       74.2% (+-2.2%)
 190 74b71   9ucb1amaf#      77% (+-2.1%)    pattern2=0
 191 74b71   13ucb1amaf      46.8% (+-2.5%)
 192 74b71   13ucb1amaf#     50.2% (+-2.5%)  pattern2=0
 193
 194 e34f9   9ucb1amaf       74.2% (+-2.2%)
 195 e34f9   9ucb1amaf#      74% (+-2.2%)    pattern2=0
 196 e34f9   9ucb1amaf*      76% (+-2.1%)    atarirate=0
 197 e34f9   9ucb1amaf#*     79% (+-2%)      pattern2=0,atarirate=0
 198 e34f9   13ucb1amaf      47.2% (+-2.5%)
 199 e34f9   13ucb1amaf#     49.7% (+-2.8%)  pattern2=0
 200 e34f9   13ucb1amaf#*    52.2% (+-2.5%)  pattern2=0,atarirate=0
 201
 202 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf       78.2% (+-2.1%)
 203 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf#      81.8% (+-1.9%)  pattern2=0
 204 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf*      74.5% (+-2.2%)  atarirate=0
 205 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf#*     75.5% (+-2.2%)  pattern2=0,atarirate=0
 206 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf#*+    78.5% (+-2.1%)  pattern2=0,atarirate=0,prior_cfgd=6
 207 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf+%     81.2% (+-2%)    prior_cfgd=6,prior_b19=6
 208 ba2e1   9ucb1amaf#+%    83% (+-1.9%)    pattern2=0,prior_cfgd=6,prior_b19=6
 209
 210 ba2e1   13ucb1amaf+     57% (+-2.5%)    prior_cfgd=6
 211 ba2e1   13ucb1amaf+%    51.2% (+-2.5%)  prior_cfgd=6,prior_b19=6
 212 ba2e1   13ucb1amaf#*+   54.8% (+-2.5%)  pattern2=0,atarirate=0,prior_cfgd=6
 213
 214 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf!+    13.8% (+-1.7%)  prior_cfgd=6,fillboard
 215 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#*+%! 9.8% (+-1.5%)   pattern2=0,atarirate=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=6,fillboard
 216 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#*+%2 25% (+-2.2%)    pattern2=0,atarirate=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20
 217 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf+%2   21.2% (+-2%)    prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20
 218 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf+%2!  20.5% (+-2%)    prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20,fillboard
 219 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf+%3   20.8% (+-2%)    prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=30
 220 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf+%4   25.8% (+-2.2%)  prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=40
 221 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf+%5   23.2% (+-2.1%)  prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=50
 222 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#+%2  26.5% (+-2.2%)  pattern2=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20
 223 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#+%2! 22.5% (+-2.1%)  pattern2=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20,fillboard
 224 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#+%2_ 23.5% (+-2.1%)  pattern2=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20,prior_policy=10
 225 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#+%2a 1% (+-0.7%)     pattern2=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20,playouts=1000
 226 ba2e1   19ucb1amaf#+%2b 7.2% (+-1.4%)   pattern2=0,prior_cfgd=prior_b19=prior=20,playouts=2000
 227
 228
 229
 230 TODO: playout_amaf with weight 1/2, sibling_amaf with weight 1, 1/2