| blob | 45a09a8fb1dee33fc9df1c9867a6ff5d3b224765 |
1 <?xml version="1.0" encoding="iso-8859-1"?>
2 <!DOCTYPE chapter PUBLIC "-//Samba-Team//DTD DocBook V4.2-Based Variant V1.0//EN" "http://www.samba.org/samba/DTD/samba-doc">
3 <chapter id="unixclients">
4 <title>Adding Domain Member Servers and Clients</title>
6 <para><indexterm>
7 <primary>Open Magazine</primary>
8 </indexterm><indexterm>
9 <primary>survey</primary>
10 </indexterm>
11 The most frequently discussed Samba subjects over the past 2 years have focused around domain control and printing.
12 It is well known that Samba is a file and print server. A recent survey conducted by <emphasis>Open Magazine</emphasis> found
13 that of all respondents, 97 percent use Samba for file and print services, and 68 percent use Samba for Domain Control. See the
14 <ulink url="http://www.open-mag.com/cgi-bin/opencgi/surveys/survey.cgi?survey_name=samba">Open-Mag</ulink>
15 Web site for current information. The survey results as found on January 14, 2004, are shown in
16 <link linkend="ch09openmag"/>.
17 </para>
19 <figure id="ch09openmag">
20 <title>Open Magazine Samba Survey</title>
21 <imagefile scale="60">openmag</imagefile>
22 </figure>
24 <para>
25 While domain control is an exciting subject, basic file and print sharing remains the staple bread-and-butter
26 function that Samba provides. Yet this book may give the appearance of having focused too much on more
27 exciting aspects of Samba deployment. This chapter directs your attention to provide important information on
28 the addition of Samba servers into your present Windows network &smbmdash; whatever the controlling technology
29 may be. So let's get back to our good friends at Abmas.
30 </para>
32 <sect1>
33 <title>Introduction</title>
35 <para><indexterm>
36 <primary>Linux desktop</primary>
37 </indexterm><indexterm>
38 <primary>Domain Member</primary>
39 <secondary>server</secondary>
40 </indexterm>
41 Looking back over the achievements of the past year or two, daily events at Abmas are rather straightforward
42 with not too many distractions or problems. Your team is doing well, but a number of employees
43 are asking for Linux desktop systems. Your network has grown and demands additional domain member servers. Let's
44 get on with this; Christine and Stan are ready to go.
45 </para>
47 <para><indexterm>
48 <primary>Domain Member</primary>
49 <secondary>desktop</secondary>
50 </indexterm>
51 Stan is firmly in control of the department of the future, while Christine is enjoying a stable and
52 predictable network environment. It is time to add more servers and to add Linux desktops. It is
53 time to meet the demands of future growth and endure trial by fire.
54 </para>
56 <sect2>
57 <title>Assignment Tasks</title>
59 <para><indexterm>
60 <primary>Active Directory</primary>
61 </indexterm>
62 You must now add UNIX/Linux domain member servers to your network. You have a friend who has a Windows 2003
63 Active Directory domain network who wants to add a Samba/Linux server and has asked Christine to help him
64 out. Your real objective is to help Christine to see more of the way the Microsoft world lives and use
65 her help to get validation that Samba really does live up to expectations.
66 </para>
68 <para>
69 Over the past 6 months, you have hired several new staff who want Linux on their desktops. You must integrate
70 these systems to make sure that Abmas is not building islands of technology. You ask Christine to
71 do likewise at Swodniw Biz NL (your friend's company) to help them to evaluate a Linux desktop. You want to make
72 the right decision, don't you?
73 </para>
75 </sect2>
76 </sect1>
78 <sect1>
79 <title>Dissection and Discussion</title>
81 <para>
82 <indexterm><primary>winbind</primary></indexterm>
83 Recent Samba mailing-list activity is witness to how many sites are using winbind. Some have no trouble
84 at all with it, yet to others the problems seem insurmountable. Periodically there are complaints concerning
85 an inability to achieve identical user and group IDs between Windows and UNIX environments.
86 </para>
88 <para>
89 You provide step-by-step implementations of the various tools that can be used for identity
90 resolution. You also provide working examples of solutions for integrated authentication for
91 both UNIX/Linux and Windows environments.
92 </para>
94 <sect2>
95 <title>Technical Issues</title>
97 <para>
98 One of the great challenges we face when people ask us, <quote>What is the best way to solve
99 this problem?</quote> is to get beyond the facts so we not only can clearly comprehend
100 the immediate technical problem, but also can understand how needs may change.
101 </para>
103 <para>
104 <indexterm><primary>integrate</primary></indexterm>
105 There are a few facts we should note when dealing with the question of how best to
106 integrate UNIX/Linux clients and servers into a Windows networking environment:
107 </para>
109 <itemizedlist>
110 <listitem><para>
111 <indexterm><primary>Domain Controller</primary></indexterm>
112 <indexterm><primary>authoritative</primary></indexterm>
113 <indexterm><primary>accounts</primary><secondary>authoritative</secondary></indexterm>
114 <indexterm><primary>PDC</primary></indexterm>
115 <indexterm><primary>BDC</primary></indexterm>
116 A domain controller (PDC or BDC) is always authoritative for all accounts in its domain.
117 This means that a BDC must (of necessity) be able to resolve all account UIDs and GIDs
118 to the same values that the PDC resolved them to.
119 </para></listitem>
121 <listitem><para>
122 <indexterm><primary>local accounts</primary></indexterm>
123 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>authoritative</secondary><tertiary>local accounts</tertiary></indexterm>
124 <indexterm><primary>Domain accounts</primary></indexterm>
125 <indexterm><primary>winbindd</primary></indexterm>
126 A domain member can be authoritative for local accounts, but is never authoritative for
127 domain accounts. If a user is accessing a domain member server and that user's account
128 is not known locally, the domain member server must resolve the identity of that user
129 from the domain in which that user's account resides. It must then map that ID to a
130 UID/GID pair that it can use locally. This is handled by <command>winbindd</command>.
131 </para></listitem>
133 <listitem><para>
134 Samba, when running on a domain member server, can resolve user identities from a
135 number of sources:
136 </para>
138 <itemizedlist>
139 <listitem><para>
140 <indexterm><primary>getpwnam</primary></indexterm>
141 <indexterm><primary>getgrnam</primary></indexterm>
142 <indexterm><primary>NSS</primary></indexterm>
143 <indexterm><primary>LDAP</primary></indexterm>
144 <indexterm><primary>NIS</primary></indexterm>
145 By executing a system <command>getpwnam()</command> or <command>getgrnam()</command> call.
146 On systems that support it, this utilizes the name service switch (NSS) facility to
147 resolve names according to the configuration of the <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename>
148 file. NSS can be configured to use LDAP, winbind, NIS, or local files.
149 </para></listitem>
151 <listitem><para>
152 <indexterm><primary>passdb backend</primary></indexterm>
153 <indexterm><primary>PADL</primary></indexterm>
154 <indexterm><primary>nss_ldap</primary></indexterm>
155 Performing, via NSS, a direct LDAP search (where an LDAP passdb backend has been configured).
156 This requires the use of the PADL nss_ldap tool (or equivalent).
157 </para></listitem>
159 <listitem><para>
160 <indexterm><primary>winbindd</primary></indexterm>
161 <indexterm><primary>SID</primary></indexterm>
162 <indexterm><primary>winbindd_idmap.tdb</primary></indexterm>
163 <indexterm><primary>winbindd_cache.tdb</primary></indexterm>
164 Directly by querying <command>winbindd</command>. The <command>winbindd</command>
165 contacts a domain controller to attempt to resolve the identity of the user or group. It
166 receives the Windows networking security identifier (SID) for that appropriate
167 account and then allocates a local UID or GID from the range of available IDs and
168 creates an entry in its <filename>winbindd_idmap.tdb</filename> and
169 <filename>winbindd_cache.tdb</filename> files.
170 </para>
172 <para>
173 <indexterm><primary>idmap backend</primary></indexterm>
174 <indexterm><primary>mapping</primary></indexterm>
175 If the parameter <smbconfoption name="idmap backend">ldap:ldap://myserver.domain</smbconfoption>
176 was specified and the LDAP server has been configured with a container in which it may
177 store the IDMAP entries, all domain members may share a common mapping.
178 </para></listitem>
179 </itemizedlist>
181 <para>
182 Irrespective of how &smb.conf; is configured, winbind creates and caches a local copy of
183 the ID mapping database. It uses the <filename>winbindd_idmap.tdb</filename> and
184 <filename>winbindd_cache.tdb</filename> files to do this.
185 </para>
187 <para>
188 Which of the resolver methods is chosen is determined by the way that Samba is configured
189 in the &smb.conf; file. Some of the configuration options are rather less than obvious to the
190 casual user.
191 </para></listitem>
193 <listitem><para>
194 <indexterm><primary>winbind trusted domains only</primary></indexterm>
195 <indexterm><primary>domain member</primary><secondary>servers</secondary></indexterm>
196 <indexterm><primary>domain controllers</primary></indexterm>
197 If you wish to make use of accounts (users and/or groups) that are local to (i.e., capable
198 of being resolved using) the NSS facility, it is possible to use the
199 <smbconfoption name="winbind trusted domains only">Yes</smbconfoption>
200 in the &smb.conf; file. This parameter specifically applies to domain controllers,
201 and to domain member servers.
202 </para></listitem>
204 </itemizedlist>
206 <para>
207 <indexterm><primary>Posix accounts</primary></indexterm>
208 <indexterm><primary>Samba accounts</primary></indexterm>
209 <indexterm><primary>LDAP</primary></indexterm>
210 For many administrators, it should be plain that the use of an LDAP-based repository for all network
211 accounts (both for POSIX accounts and for Samba accounts) provides the most elegant and
212 controllable facility. You eventually appreciate the decision to use LDAP.
213 </para>
215 <para>
216 <indexterm><primary>nss_ldap</primary></indexterm>
217 <indexterm><primary>identifiers</primary></indexterm>
218 <indexterm><primary>resolve</primary></indexterm>
219 If your network account information resides in an LDAP repository, you should use it ahead of any
220 alternative method. This means that if it is humanly possible to use the <command>nss_ldap</command>
221 tools to resolve UNIX account UIDs/GIDs via LDAP, this is the preferred solution, because it provides
222 a more readily controllable method for asserting the exact same user and group identifiers
223 throughout the network.
224 </para>
226 <para>
227 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>server</secondary></indexterm>
228 <indexterm><primary>winbind trusted domains only</primary></indexterm>
229 <indexterm><primary>getpwnam</primary></indexterm>
230 <indexterm><primary>smbd</primary></indexterm>
231 <indexterm><primary>Trusted Domains</primary></indexterm>
232 <indexterm><primary>External Domains</primary></indexterm>
233 In the situation where UNIX accounts are held on the domain member server itself, the only effective
234 way to use them involves the &smb.conf; entry
235 <smbconfoption name="winbind trusted domains only">Yes</smbconfoption>. This forces
236 Samba (<command>smbd</command>) to perform a <command>getpwnam()</command> system call that can
237 then be controlled via <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> file settings. The use of this parameter
238 disables the use of Samba with trusted domains (i.e., external domains).
239 </para>
241 <para>
242 <indexterm><primary>appliance mode</primary></indexterm>
243 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>server</secondary></indexterm>
244 <indexterm><primary>winbindd</primary></indexterm>
245 <indexterm><primary>automatically allocate</primary></indexterm>
246 Winbind can be used to create an appliance mode domain member server. In this capacity, <command>winbindd</command>
247 is configured to automatically allocate UIDs/GIDs from numeric ranges set in the &smb.conf; file. The allocation
248 is made for all accounts that connect to that domain member server, whether within its own domain or from
249 trusted domains. If not stored in an LDAP backend, each domain member maintains its own unique mapping database.
250 This means that it is almost certain that a given user who accesses two domain member servers does not have the
251 same UID/GID on both servers &smbmdash; however, this is transparent to the Windows network user. This data
252 is stored in the <filename>winbindd_idmap.tdb</filename> and <filename>winbindd_cache.tdb</filename> files.
253 </para>
255 <para>
256 <indexterm><primary>mapping</primary></indexterm>
257 The use of an LDAP backend for the Winbind IDMAP facility permits Windows domain SIDs
258 mappings to UIDs/GIDs to be stored centrally. The result is a consistent mapping across all domain member
259 servers so configured. This solves one of the major headaches for network administrators who need to copy
260 files between or across network file servers.
261 </para>
263 </sect2>
265 <sect2>
266 <title>Political Issues</title>
268 <para>
269 <indexterm><primary>OpenLDAP</primary></indexterm>
270 <indexterm><primary>NIS</primary></indexterm>
271 <indexterm><primary>yellow pages</primary><see>NIS</see></indexterm>
272 <indexterm><primary>identity management</primary></indexterm>
273 One of the most fierce conflicts recently being waged is resistance to the adoption of LDAP, in
274 particular OpenLDAP, as a replacement for UNIX NIS (previously called Yellow Pages). Let's face it, LDAP
275 is different and requires a new approach to the need for a better identity management solution. The more
276 you work with LDAP, the more its power and flexibility emerges from its dark, cavernous chasm.
277 </para>
279 <para>
280 LDAP is a most suitable solution for heterogenous environments. If you need crypto, add Kerberos.
281 The reason these are preferable is because they are heterogenous. Windows solutions of this sort are <emphasis>not</emphasis>
282 heterogenous by design. This is fundamental &smbmdash; it isn't religious or political. This also doesn't say that
283 you can't use Windows Active Directory in a heterogenous environment &smbmdash; it can be done, it just requires
284 commercial integration products. But it's not what Active Directory was designed for.
285 </para>
287 <para>
288 <indexterm><primary>directory</primary></indexterm>
289 <indexterm><primary>management</primary></indexterm>
290 A number of long-term UNIX devotees have recently commented in various communications that the Samba Team
291 is the first application group to almost force network administrators to use LDAP. It should be pointed
292 out that we resisted this for as long as we could. It is not out of laziness or malice that LDAP has
293 finally emerged as the preferred identity management backend for Samba. We recommend LDAP for your total
294 organizational directory needs.
295 </para>
297 </sect2>
299 </sect1>
301 <sect1>
302 <title>Implementation</title>
304 <para>
305 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>server</secondary></indexterm>
306 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>client</secondary></indexterm>
307 <indexterm><primary>Domain Controller</primary></indexterm>
308 The domain member server and the domain member client are at the center of focus in this chapter.
309 Configuration of Samba-3 domain controller is covered in earlier chapters, so if your
310 interest is in domain controller configuration, you will not find that here. You will find good
311 oil that helps you to add domain member servers and clients.
312 </para>
314 <para>
315 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>workstations</secondary></indexterm>
316 In practice, domain member servers and domain member workstations are very different entities, but in
317 terms of technology they share similar core infrastructure. A technologist would argue that servers
318 and workstations are identical. Many users would argue otherwise, given that in a well-disciplined
319 environment a workstation (client) is a device from which a user creates documents and files that
320 are located on servers. A workstation is frequently viewed as a disposable (easy to replace) item,
321 but a server is viewed as a core component of the business.
322 </para>
324 <para>
325 <indexterm><primary>workstation</primary></indexterm>
326 We can look at this another way. If a workstation breaks down, one user is affected, but if a
327 server breaks down, hundreds of users may not be able to work. The services that a workstation
328 must provide are document- and file-production oriented; a server provides information storage
329 and is distribution oriented.
330 </para>
332 <para>
333 <indexterm><primary>authentication process</primary></indexterm>
334 <indexterm><primary>logon process</primary></indexterm>
335 <indexterm><primary>user identities</primary></indexterm>
336 <emphasis>Why is this important?</emphasis> For starters, we must identify what
337 components of the operating system and its environment must be configured. Also, it is necessary
338 to recognize where the interdependencies between the various services to be used are.
339 In particular, it is important to understand the operation of each critical part of the
340 authentication process, the logon process, and how user identities get resolved and applied
341 within the operating system and applications (like Samba) that depend on this and may
342 actually contribute to it.
343 </para>
345 <para>
346 So, in this chapter we demonstrate how to implement the technology. It is done within a context of
347 what type of service need must be fulfilled.
348 </para>
350 <sect2 id="sdcsdmldap">
351 <title>Samba Domain with Samba Domain Member Server &smbmdash; Using NSS LDAP</title>
353 <para>
354 <indexterm><primary>ldapsam</primary></indexterm>
355 <indexterm><primary>ldapsam backend</primary></indexterm>
356 <indexterm><primary>IDMAP</primary></indexterm>
357 <indexterm><primary>mapping</primary><secondary>consistent</secondary></indexterm>
358 <indexterm><primary>winbindd</primary></indexterm>
359 <indexterm><primary>foreign SID</primary></indexterm>
360 In this example, it is assumed that you have Samba PDC/BDC servers. This means you are using
361 an LDAP ldapsam backend. We are adding to the LDAP backend database (directory)
362 containers for use by the IDMAP facility. This makes it possible to have globally consistent
363 mapping of SIDs to and from UIDs and GIDs. This means that it is necessary to run
364 <command>winbindd</command> as part of your configuration. The primary purpose of running
365 <command>winbindd</command> (within this operational context) is to permit mapping of foreign
366 SIDs (those not originating from the the local Samba server). Foreign SIDs can come from any
367 domain member client or server, or from Windows clients that do not belong to a domain. Another
368 way to explain the necessity to run <command>winbindd</command> is that Samba can locally
369 resolve only accounts that belong to the security context of its own machine SID. Winbind
370 handles all non-local SIDs and maps them to a local UID/GID value. The UID and GID are allocated
371 from the parameter values set in the &smb.conf; file for the <parameter>idmap uid</parameter> and
372 <parameter>idmap gid</parameter> ranges. Where LDAP is used, the mappings can be stored in LDAP
373 so that all domain member servers can use a consistent mapping.
374 </para>
376 <para>
377 <indexterm><primary>winbindd</primary></indexterm>
378 <indexterm><primary>getpwnam</primary></indexterm>
379 <indexterm><primary>NSS</primary></indexterm>
380 If your installation is accessed only from clients that are members of your own domain, and all
381 user accounts are present in a local passdb backend then it is not necessary to run
382 <command>winbindd</command>. The local passdb backend can be in smbpasswd, tdbsam, or in ldapsam.
383 </para>
385 <para>
386 It is possible to use a local passdb backend with any convenient means of resolving the POSIX
387 user and group account information. The POSIX information is usually obtained using the
388 <command>getpwnam()</command> system call. On NSS-enabled systems, the actual POSIX account
389 source can be provided from
390 </para>
392 <itemizedlist>
393 <listitem><para>
394 <indexterm><primary>/etc/passwd</primary></indexterm>
395 <indexterm><primary>/etc/group</primary></indexterm>
396 Accounts in <filename>/etc/passwd</filename> or in <filename>/etc/group</filename>.
397 </para></listitem>
399 <listitem><para>
400 <indexterm><primary>NSS</primary></indexterm>
401 <indexterm><primary>compat</primary></indexterm>
402 <indexterm><primary>ldap</primary></indexterm>
403 <indexterm><primary>nis</primary></indexterm>
404 <indexterm><primary>nisplus</primary></indexterm>
405 <indexterm><primary>hesiod</primary></indexterm>
406 <indexterm><primary>ldap</primary></indexterm>
407 <indexterm><primary>nss_ldap</primary></indexterm>
408 <indexterm><primary>PADL Software</primary></indexterm>
409 Resolution via NSS. On NSS-enabled systems, there is usually a facility to resolve IDs
410 via multiple methods. The methods typically include <command>files</command>,
411 <command>compat</command>, <command>db</command>, <command>ldap</command>,
412 <command>nis</command>, <command>nisplus</command>, <command>hesiod.</command> When
413 correctly installed, Samba adds to this list the <command>winbindd</command> facility.
414 The ldap facility is frequently the nss_ldap tool provided by PADL Software.
415 </para></listitem>
416 </itemizedlist>
418 <note><para>
419 To advoid confusion the use of the term <literal>local passdb backend</literal> means that
420 the user account backend is not shared by any other Samba server &smbmdash; instead, it is
421 used only locally on the Samba domain member server under discussion.
422 </para></note>
424 <para>
425 <indexterm><primary>Identity resolution</primary></indexterm>
426 The diagram in <link linkend="ch9-sambadc"/> demonstrates the relationship of Samba and system
427 components that are involved in the identity resolution process where Samba is used as a domain
428 member server within a Samba domain control network.
429 </para>
431 <figure id="ch9-sambadc">
432 <title>Samba Domain: Samba Member Server</title>
433 <imagefile scale="60">chap9-SambaDC</imagefile>
434 </figure>
436 <para>
437 <indexterm><primary>IDMAP</primary></indexterm>
438 <indexterm><primary>foreign</primary></indexterm>
439 In this example configuration, Samba will directly search the LDAP-based passwd backend ldapsam
440 to obtain authentication and user identity information. The IDMAP information is stored in the LDAP
441 backend so that it can be shared by all domain member servers so that every user will have a
442 consistent UID and GID across all of them. The IDMAP facility will be used for all foreign
443 (i.e., not having the same SID as the domain it is a member of) domains. The configuration of
444 NSS will ensure that all UNIX processes will obtain a consistent UID/GID.
445 </para>
447 <para>
448 The instructions given here apply to the Samba environment shown in <link linkend="happy"/> and <link linkend="net2000users"/>.
449 If the network does not have an LDAP slave server (i.e., <link linkend="happy"/> configuration),
450 change the target LDAP server from <constant>lapdc</constant> to <constant>massive.</constant>
451 </para>
453 <procedure>
454 <title>Configuration of NSS_LDAP-Based Identity Resolution</title>
456 <step><para>
457 Create the &smb.conf; file as shown in <link linkend="ch9-sdmsdc"/>. Locate
458 this file in the directory <filename>/etc/samba</filename>.
459 </para></step>
461 <step><para>
462 <indexterm><primary>ldap.conf</primary></indexterm>
463 Configure the file that will be used by <constant>nss_ldap</constant> to
464 locate and communicate with the LDAP server. This file is called <filename>ldap.conf</filename>.
465 If your implementation of <constant>nss_ldap</constant> is consistent with
466 the defaults suggested by PADL (the authors), it will be located in the
467 <filename>/etc</filename> directory. On some systems, the default location is
468 the <filename>/etc/openldap</filename> directory, however this file is intended
469 for use by the OpenLDAP utilities and should not really be used by the nss_ldap
470 utility since its content and structure serves the specific purpose of enabling
471 the resolution of user and group IDs via NSS.
472 </para>
474 <para>
475 Change the parameters inside the file that is located on your OS so it matches
476 <link linkend="ch9-sdmlcnf"/>. To find the correct location of this file, you
477 can obtain this from the library that will be used by executing the following:
478 <screen>
479 &rootprompt; strings /lib/libnss_ldap* | grep ldap.conf
480 /etc/ldap.conf
481 </screen>
482 </para></step>
484 <step><para>
485 Configure the NSS control file so it matches the one shown in
486 <link linkend="ch9-sdmnss"/>.
487 </para></step>
489 <step><para>
490 <indexterm><primary>Identity resolution</primary></indexterm>
491 <indexterm><primary>getent</primary></indexterm>
492 Before proceeding to configure Samba, validate the operation of the NSS identity
493 resolution via LDAP by executing:
494 <screen>
495 &rootprompt; getent passwd
496 ...
497 root:x:0:512:Netbios Domain Administrator:/root:/bin/false
498 nobody:x:999:514:nobody:/dev/null:/bin/false
499 bobj:x:1000:513:Robert Jordan:/home/bobj:/bin/bash
500 stans:x:1001:513:Stanley Soroka:/home/stans:/bin/bash
501 chrisr:x:1002:513:Christine Roberson:/home/chrisr:/bin/bash
502 maryv:x:1003:513:Mary Vortexis:/home/maryv:/bin/bash
503 jht:x:1004:513:John H Terpstra:/home/jht:/bin/bash
504 bldg1$:x:1006:553:bldg1$:/dev/null:/bin/false
505 temptation$:x:1009:553:temptation$:/dev/null:/bin/false
506 vaioboss$:x:1005:553:vaioboss$:/dev/null:/bin/false
507 fran$:x:1008:553:fran$:/dev/null:/bin/false
508 josephj:x:1007:513:Joseph James:/home/josephj:/bin/bash
509 </screen>
510 You should notice the location of the users' home directories. First, make certain that
511 the home directories exist on the domain member server; otherwise, the home directory
512 share is not available. The home directories could be mounted off a domain controller
513 using NFS or by any other suitable means. Second, the absence of the domain name in the
514 home directory path is indicative that identity resolution is not being done via winbind.
515 <screen>
516 &rootprompt; getent group
517 ...
518 Domain Admins:x:512:root,jht
519 Domain Users:x:513:bobj,stans,chrisr,maryv,jht,josephj
520 Domain Guests:x:514:
521 Accounts:x:1000:
522 Finances:x:1001:
523 PIOps:x:1002:
524 sammy:x:4321:
525 </screen>
526 <indexterm><primary>secondary group</primary></indexterm>
527 <indexterm><primary>primary group</primary></indexterm>
528 <indexterm><primary>group membership</primary></indexterm>
529 This shows that all is working as it should be. Notice that in the LDAP database
530 the users' primary and secondary group memberships are identical. It is not
531 necessary to add secondary group memberships (in the group database) if the
532 user is already a member via primary group membership in the password database.
533 When using winbind, it is in fact undesirable to do this because it results in
534 doubling up of group memberships and may cause problems with winbind under certain
535 conditions. It is intended that these limitations with winbind will be resolved soon
536 after Samba-3.0.20 has been released.
537 </para></step>
539 <step><para>
540 <indexterm><primary>slapcat</primary></indexterm>
541 The LDAP directory must have a container object for IDMAP data. There are several ways you can
542 check that your LDAP database is able to receive IDMAP information. One of the simplest is to
543 execute:
544 <screen>
545 &rootprompt; slapcat | grep -i idmap
546 dn: ou=Idmap,dc=abmas,dc=biz
547 ou: idmap
548 </screen>
549 <indexterm><primary>ldapadd</primary></indexterm>
550 If the execution of this command does not return IDMAP entries, you need to create an LDIF
551 template file (see <link linkend="ch9-ldifadd"/>). You can add the required entries using
552 the following command:
553 <screen>
554 &rootprompt; ldapadd -x -D "cn=Manager,dc=abmas,dc=biz" \
555 -w not24get < /etc/openldap/idmap.LDIF
556 </screen>
557 </para></step>
559 <step><para>
560 Samba automatically populates the LDAP directory container when it needs to. To permit Samba
561 write access to the LDAP directory it is necessary to set the LDAP administrative password
562 in the <filename>secrets.tdb</filename> file as shown here:
563 <screen>
564 &rootprompt; smbpasswd -w not24get
565 </screen>
566 </para></step>
568 <step><para>
569 <indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>rpc</secondary><tertiary>join</tertiary></indexterm>
570 <indexterm><primary>Domain join</primary></indexterm>
571 The system is ready to join the domain. Execute the following:
572 <screen>
573 &rootprompt; net rpc join -U root%not24get
574 Joined domain MEGANET2.
575 </screen>
576 This indicates that the domain join succeeded.
577 </para>
579 <para>
580 Failure to join the domain could be caused by any number of variables. The most common
581 causes of failure to join are:
582 </para>
584 <para>
585 <itemizedlist>
586 <listitem><para>Broken resolution of NetBIOS names to the respective IP address.</para></listitem>
587 <listitem><para>Incorrect username and password credentials.</para></listitem>
588 <listitem><para>The NT4 <parameter>restrict anonymous</parameter> is set to exclude anonymous
589 connections.</para></listitem>
590 </itemizedlist>
591 </para>
593 <para>
594 The connection setup can be diagnosed by executing:
595 <screen>
596 &rootprompt; net rpc join -S 'pdc-name' -U administrator%password -d 5
597 </screen>
598 <indexterm><primary>failed</primary></indexterm>
599 <indexterm><primary>failed join</primary></indexterm>
600 <indexterm><primary>rejected</primary></indexterm>
601 <indexterm><primary>restrict anonymous</primary></indexterm>
602 Note: Use "root" for UNIX/Linux and Samba, use "Administrator" for Windows NT4/200X. If the cause of
603 the failure appears to be related to a rejected or failed NT_SESSION_SETUP* or an error message that
604 says NT_STATUS_ACCESS_DENIED immediately check the Windows registry setting that controls the
605 <constant>restrict anonymous</constant> setting. Set this to the value 0 so that an anonymous connection
606 can be sustained, then try again.
607 </para>
609 <para>
610 It is possible (perhaps even recommended) to use the following to validate the ability to connect
611 to an NT4 PDC/BDC:
612 <screen>
613 &rootprompt; net rpc info -S 'pdc-name' -U Administrator%not24get
614 Domain Name: MEGANET2
615 Domain SID: S-1-5-21-422319763-4138913805-7168186429
616 Sequence number: 1519909596
617 Num users: 7003
618 Num domain groups: 821
619 Num local groups: 8
621 &rootprompt; net rpc testjoin -S 'pdc-name' -U Administrator%not24get
622 Join to 'MEGANET2' is OK
623 </screen>
624 If for any reason the following response is obtained to the last command above,it is time to
625 call in the Networking Super-Snooper task force (i.e., start debugging):
626 <screen>
627 NT_STATUS_ACCESS_DENIED
628 Join to 'MEGANET2' failed.
629 </screen>
630 </para></step>
632 <step><para>
633 <indexterm><primary>wbinfo</primary></indexterm>
634 Just joining the domain is not quite enough; you must now provide a privileged set
635 of credentials through which <command>winbindd</command> can interact with the
636 domain servers. Execute the following to implant the necessary credentials:
637 <screen>
638 &rootprompt; wbinfo --set-auth-user=Administrator%not24get
639 </screen>
640 The configuration is now ready to obtain the Samba domain user and group information.
641 </para></step>
643 <step><para>
644 You may now start Samba in the usual manner, and your Samba domain member server
645 is ready for use. Just add shares as required.
646 </para></step>
648 </procedure>
650 <example id="ch9-sdmsdc">
651 <title>Samba Domain Member in Samba Domain Using LDAP &smbmdash; &smb.conf; File</title>
652 <smbconfblock>
653 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
654 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
655 <smbconfoption name="unix charset">LOCALE</smbconfoption>
656 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">MEGANET2</smbconfoption>
657 <smbconfoption name="security">DOMAIN</smbconfoption>
658 <smbconfoption name="username map">/etc/samba/smbusers</smbconfoption>
659 <smbconfoption name="log level">10</smbconfoption>
660 <smbconfoption name="syslog">0</smbconfoption>
661 <smbconfoption name="log file">/var/log/samba/%m</smbconfoption>
662 <smbconfoption name="max log size">50</smbconfoption>
663 <smbconfoption name="smb ports">139</smbconfoption>
664 <smbconfoption name="name resolve order">wins bcast hosts</smbconfoption>
665 <smbconfoption name="printcap name">CUPS</smbconfoption>
666 <smbconfoption name="wins server">192.168.2.1</smbconfoption>
667 <smbconfoption name="ldap suffix">dc=abmas,dc=biz</smbconfoption>
668 <smbconfoption name="ldap machine suffix">ou=People</smbconfoption>
669 <smbconfoption name="ldap user suffix">ou=People</smbconfoption>
670 <smbconfoption name="ldap group suffix">ou=Groups</smbconfoption>
671 <smbconfoption name="ldap idmap suffix">ou=Idmap</smbconfoption>
672 <smbconfoption name="ldap admin dn">cn=Manager,dc=abmas,dc=biz</smbconfoption>
673 <smbconfoption name="idmap backend">ldap:ldap://lapdc.abmas.biz</smbconfoption>
674 <smbconfoption name="idmap uid">10000-20000</smbconfoption>
675 <smbconfoption name="idmap gid">10000-20000</smbconfoption>
676 <smbconfoption name="winbind trusted domains only">Yes</smbconfoption>
677 <smbconfoption name="printing">cups</smbconfoption>
679 <smbconfsection name="[homes]"/>
680 <smbconfoption name="comment">Home Directories</smbconfoption>
681 <smbconfoption name="valid users">%S</smbconfoption>
682 <smbconfoption name="read only">No</smbconfoption>
683 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
685 <smbconfsection name="[printers]"/>
686 <smbconfoption name="comment">SMB Print Spool</smbconfoption>
687 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/spool/samba</smbconfoption>
688 <smbconfoption name="guest ok">Yes</smbconfoption>
689 <smbconfoption name="printable">Yes</smbconfoption>
690 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
692 <smbconfsection name="[print$]"/>
693 <smbconfoption name="comment">Printer Drivers</smbconfoption>
694 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/lib/samba/drivers</smbconfoption>
695 <smbconfoption name="admin users">root, Administrator</smbconfoption>
696 <smbconfoption name="write list">root</smbconfoption>
697 </smbconfblock>
698 </example>
700 <example id="ch9-ldifadd">
701 <title>LDIF IDMAP Add-On Load File &smbmdash; File: /etc/openldap/idmap.LDIF</title>
702 <screen>
703 dn: ou=Idmap,dc=abmas,dc=biz
704 objectClass: organizationalUnit
705 ou: idmap
706 structuralObjectClass: organizationalUnit
707 </screen>
708 </example>
710 <example id="ch9-sdmlcnf">
711 <title>Configuration File for NSS LDAP Support &smbmdash; <filename>/etc/ldap.conf</filename></title>
712 <screen>
713 URI ldap://massive.abmas.biz ldap://massive.abmas.biz:636
714 host 192.168.2.1
715 base dc=abmas,dc=biz
716 binddn cn=Manager,dc=abmas,dc=biz
717 bindpw not24get
719 pam_password exop
721 nss_base_passwd ou=People,dc=abmas,dc=biz?one
722 nss_base_shadow ou=People,dc=abmas,dc=biz?one
723 nss_base_group ou=Groups,dc=abmas,dc=biz?one
724 ssl no
725 </screen>
726 </example>
728 <example id="ch9-sdmnss">
729 <title>NSS using LDAP for Identity Resolution &smbmdash; File: <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename></title>
730 <screen>
731 passwd: files ldap
732 shadow: files ldap
733 group: files ldap
735 hosts: files dns wins
736 networks: files dns
738 services: files
739 protocols: files
740 rpc: files
741 ethers: files
742 netmasks: files
743 netgroup: files
744 publickey: files
746 bootparams: files
747 automount: files
748 aliases: files
749 </screen>
750 </example>
752 </sect2>
754 <sect2 id="wdcsdm">
755 <title>NT4/Samba Domain with Samba Domain Member Server: Using NSS and Winbind</title>
757 <para>
758 You need to use this method for creating a Samba domain member server if any of the following conditions
759 prevail:
760 </para>
762 <itemizedlist>
763 <listitem><para>
764 LDAP support (client) is not installed on the system.
765 </para></listitem>
767 <listitem><para>
768 There are mitigating circumstances forcing a decision not to use LDAP.
769 </para></listitem>
771 <listitem><para>
772 The Samba domain member server must be part of a Windows NT4 Domain, or a Samba Domain.
773 </para></listitem>
774 </itemizedlist>
776 <para>
777 <indexterm><primary>Windows ADS Domain</primary></indexterm>
778 <indexterm><primary>Samba Domain</primary></indexterm>
779 <indexterm><primary>LDAP</primary></indexterm>
780 Later in the chapter, you can see how to configure a Samba domain member server for a Windows ADS domain.
781 Right now your objective is to configure a Samba server that can be a member of a Windows NT4-style
782 domain and/or does not use LDAP.
783 </para>
785 <note><para>
786 <indexterm><primary>duplicate accounts</primary></indexterm>
787 If you use <command>winbind</command> for identity resolution, make sure that there are no
788 duplicate accounts.
789 </para>
791 <para>
792 <indexterm><primary>/etc/passwd</primary></indexterm>
793 For example, do not have more than one account that has UID=0 in the password database. If there
794 is an account called <constant>root</constant> in the <filename>/etc/passwd</filename> database,
795 it is okay to have an account called <constant>root</constant> in the LDAP ldapsam or in the
796 tdbsam. But if there are two accounts in the passdb backend that have the same UID, winbind will
797 break. This means that the <constant>Administrator</constant> account must be called
798 <constant>root</constant>.
799 </para>
801 <para>
802 <indexterm><primary>/etc/passwd</primary></indexterm>
803 <indexterm><primary>ldapsam</primary></indexterm>
804 <indexterm><primary>tdbsam</primary></indexterm>
805 Winbind will break if there is an account in <filename>/etc/passwd</filename> that has
806 the same UID as an account that is in LDAP ldapsam (or in tdbsam) but that differs in name only.
807 </para></note>
809 <para>
810 <indexterm><primary>credentials</primary></indexterm>
811 <indexterm><primary>traverse</primary></indexterm>
812 <indexterm><primary>wide-area</primary></indexterm>
813 <indexterm><primary>network</primary><secondary>wide-area</secondary></indexterm>
814 <indexterm><primary>tdbdump</primary></indexterm>
815 The following configuration uses CIFS/SMB protocols alone to obtain user and group credentials.
816 The winbind information is locally cached in the <filename>winbindd_cache.tdb winbindd_idmap.tdb</filename>
817 files. This provides considerable performance benefits compared with the LDAP solution, particularly
818 where the LDAP lookups must traverse WAN links. You may examine the contents of these
819 files using the tool <command>tdbdump</command>, though you may have to build this from the Samba
820 source code if it has not been supplied as part of a binary package distribution that you may be using.
821 </para>
823 <procedure>
824 <title>Configuration of Winbind-Based Identity Resolution</title>
826 <step><para>
827 Using your favorite text editor, create the &smb.conf; file so it has the contents
828 shown in <link linkend="ch0-NT4DSDM"/>.
829 </para></step>
831 <step><para>
832 <indexterm><primary>/etc/nsswitch.conf</primary></indexterm>
833 Edit the <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> so it has the entries shown in
834 <link linkend="ch9-sdmnss"/>.
835 </para></step>
837 <step><para>
838 <indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>rpc</secondary><tertiary>join</tertiary></indexterm>
839 The system is ready to join the domain. Execute the following:
840 <screen>
841 net rpc join -U root%not2g4et
842 Joined domain MEGANET2.
843 </screen>
844 This indicates that the domain join succeed.
846 </para></step>
848 <step><para>
849 <indexterm><primary>winbind</primary></indexterm>
850 <indexterm><primary>wbinfo</primary></indexterm>
851 Validate operation of <command>winbind</command> using the <command>wbinfo</command>
852 tool as follows:
853 <screen>
854 &rootprompt; wbinfo -u
855 MEGANET2+root
856 MEGANET2+nobody
857 MEGANET2+jht
858 MEGANET2+maryv
859 MEGANET2+billr
860 MEGANET2+jelliott
861 MEGANET2+dbrady
862 MEGANET2+joeg
863 MEGANET2+balap
864 </screen>
865 This shows that domain users have been listed correctly.
866 <screen>
867 &rootprompt; wbinfo -g
868 MEGANET2+Domain Admins
869 MEGANET2+Domain Users
870 MEGANET2+Domain Guests
871 MEGANET2+Accounts
872 MEGANET2+Finances
873 MEGANET2+PIOps
874 </screen>
875 This shows that domain groups have been correctly obtained also.
876 </para></step>
878 <step><para>
879 <indexterm><primary>NSS</primary></indexterm>
880 <indexterm><primary>getent</primary></indexterm>
881 <indexterm><primary>winbind</primary></indexterm>
882 The next step verifies that NSS is able to obtain this information
883 correctly from <command>winbind</command> also.
884 <screen>
885 &rootprompt; getent passwd
886 ...
887 MEGANET2+root:x:10000:10001:NetBIOS Domain Admin:
888 /home/MEGANET2/root:/bin/bash
889 MEGANET2+nobody:x:10001:10001:nobody:
890 /home/MEGANET2/nobody:/bin/bash
891 MEGANET2+jht:x:10002:10001:John H Terpstra:
892 /home/MEGANET2/jht:/bin/bash
893 MEGANET2+maryv:x:10003:10001:Mary Vortexis:
894 /home/MEGANET2/maryv:/bin/bash
895 MEGANET2+billr:x:10004:10001:William Randalph:
896 /home/MEGANET2/billr:/bin/bash
897 MEGANET2+jelliott:x:10005:10001:John G Elliott:
898 /home/MEGANET2/jelliott:/bin/bash
899 MEGANET2+dbrady:x:10006:10001:Darren Brady:
900 /home/MEGANET2/dbrady:/bin/bash
901 MEGANET2+joeg:x:10007:10001:Joe Green:
902 /home/MEGANET2/joeg:/bin/bash
903 MEGANET2+balap:x:10008:10001:Bala Pillay:
904 /home/MEGANET2/balap:/bin/bash
905 </screen>
906 The user account information has been correctly obtained. This information has
907 been merged with the winbind template information configured in the &smb.conf; file.
908 <screen>
909 &rootprompt;# getent group
910 ...
911 MEGANET2+Domain Admins:x:10000:MEGANET2+root,MEGANET2+jht
912 MEGANET2+Domain Users:x:10001:MEGANET2+jht,MEGANET2+maryv,\
913 MEGANET2+billr,MEGANET2+jelliott,MEGANET2+dbrady,\
914 MEGANET2+joeg,MEGANET2+balap
915 MEGANET2+Domain Guests:x:10002:MEGANET2+nobody
916 MEGANET2+Accounts:x:10003:
917 MEGANET2+Finances:x:10004:
918 MEGANET2+PIOps:x:10005:
919 </screen>
920 </para></step>
922 <step><para>
923 The Samba member server of a Windows NT4 domain is ready for use.
924 </para></step>
926 </procedure>
928 <example id="ch0-NT4DSDM">
929 <title>Samba Domain Member Server Using Winbind &smb.conf; File for NT4 Domain</title>
930 <smbconfblock>
931 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
932 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
933 <smbconfoption name="unix charset">LOCALE</smbconfoption>
934 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">MEGANET2</smbconfoption>
935 <smbconfoption name="security">DOMAIN</smbconfoption>
936 <smbconfoption name="username map">/etc/samba/smbusers</smbconfoption>
937 <smbconfoption name="log level">1</smbconfoption>
938 <smbconfoption name="syslog">0</smbconfoption>
939 <smbconfoption name="log file">/var/log/samba/%m</smbconfoption>
940 <smbconfoption name="max log size">0</smbconfoption>
941 <smbconfoption name="smb ports">139</smbconfoption>
942 <smbconfoption name="name resolve order">wins bcast hosts</smbconfoption>
943 <smbconfoption name="printcap name">CUPS</smbconfoption>
944 <smbconfoption name="wins server">192.168.2.1</smbconfoption>
945 <smbconfoption name="idmap uid">10000-20000</smbconfoption>
946 <smbconfoption name="idmap gid">10000-20000</smbconfoption>
947 <smbconfoption name="template primary group">"Domain Users"</smbconfoption>
948 <smbconfoption name="template shell">/bin/bash</smbconfoption>
949 <smbconfoption name="winbind separator">+</smbconfoption>
950 <smbconfoption name="hosts allow">192.168.2., 192.168.3., 127.</smbconfoption>
951 <smbconfoption name="printing">cups</smbconfoption>
953 <smbconfsection name="[homes]"/>
954 <smbconfoption name="comment">Home Directories</smbconfoption>
955 <smbconfoption name="valid users">%S</smbconfoption>
956 <smbconfoption name="read only">No</smbconfoption>
957 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
959 <smbconfsection name="[printers]"/>
960 <smbconfoption name="comment">SMB Print Spool</smbconfoption>
961 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/spool/samba</smbconfoption>
962 <smbconfoption name="guest ok">Yes</smbconfoption>
963 <smbconfoption name="printable">Yes</smbconfoption>
964 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
966 <smbconfsection name="[print$]"/>
967 <smbconfoption name="comment">Printer Drivers</smbconfoption>
968 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/lib/samba/drivers</smbconfoption>
969 <smbconfoption name="admin users">root, Administrator</smbconfoption>
970 <smbconfoption name="write list">root</smbconfoption>
971 </smbconfblock>
972 </example>
974 </sect2>
976 <sect2 id="dcwonss">
977 <title>NT4/Samba Domain with Samba Domain Member Server without NSS Support</title>
979 <para>
980 No matter how many UNIX/Linux administrators there may be who believe that a UNIX operating
981 system that does not have NSS and PAM support to be outdated, the fact is there
982 are still many such systems in use today. Samba can be used without NSS support, but this
983 does limit it to the use of local user and group accounts only.
984 </para>
986 <para>
987 The following steps may be followed to implement Samba with support for local accounts.
988 In this configuration Samba is made a domain member server. All incoming connections
989 to the Samba server will cause the look-up of the incoming username. If the account
990 is found, it is used. If the account is not found, one will be automatically created
991 on the local machine so that it can then be used for all access controls.
992 </para>
994 <procedure>
995 <title>Configuration Using Local Accounts Only</title>
997 <step><para>
998 Using your favorite text editor, create the &smb.conf; file so it has the contents
999 shown in <link linkend="ch0-NT4DSCM"/>.
1000 </para></step>
1002 <step>
1003 <para><indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>rpc</secondary><tertiary>join</tertiary></indexterm>
1004 The system is ready to join the domain. Execute the following:
1005 <screen>
1006 net rpc join -U root%not24get
1007 Joined domain MEGANET2.
1008 </screen>
1009 This indicates that the domain join succeed.
1010 </para></step>
1012 <step><para>
1013 Be sure to run all three Samba daemons: <command>smbd</command>, <command>nmbd</command>, <command>winbindd</command>.
1014 </para></step>
1016 <step><para>
1017 The Samba member server of a Windows NT4 domain is ready for use.
1018 </para></step>
1019 </procedure>
1021 <example id="ch0-NT4DSCM">
1022 <title>Samba Domain Member Server Using Local Accounts &smb.conf; File for NT4 Domain</title>
1023 <smbconfblock>
1024 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
1025 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
1026 <smbconfoption name="unix charset">LOCALE</smbconfoption>
1027 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">MEGANET3</smbconfoption>
1028 <smbconfoption name="netbios name">BSDBOX</smbconfoption>
1029 <smbconfoption name="security">DOMAIN</smbconfoption>
1030 <smbconfoption name="username map">/etc/samba/smbusers</smbconfoption>
1031 <smbconfoption name="log level">1</smbconfoption>
1032 <smbconfoption name="syslog">0</smbconfoption>
1033 <smbconfoption name="add user script">/usr/sbin/useradd -m '%u'</smbconfoption>
1034 <smbconfoption name="add machine script">/usr/sbin/useradd -M '%u'</smbconfoption>
1035 <smbconfoption name="add group script">/usr/sbin/groupadd '%g'</smbconfoption>
1036 <smbconfoption name="log file">/var/log/samba/%m</smbconfoption>
1037 <smbconfoption name="max log size">0</smbconfoption>
1038 <smbconfoption name="smb ports">139</smbconfoption>
1039 <smbconfoption name="name resolve order">wins bcast hosts</smbconfoption>
1040 <smbconfoption name="printcap name">CUPS</smbconfoption>
1041 <smbconfoption name="wins server">192.168.2.1</smbconfoption>
1042 <smbconfoption name="hosts allow">192.168.2., 192.168.3., 127.</smbconfoption>
1043 <smbconfoption name="printing">cups</smbconfoption>
1045 <smbconfsection name="[homes]"/>
1046 <smbconfoption name="comment">Home Directories</smbconfoption>
1047 <smbconfoption name="valid users">%S</smbconfoption>
1048 <smbconfoption name="read only">No</smbconfoption>
1049 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
1051 <smbconfsection name="[printers]"/>
1052 <smbconfoption name="comment">SMB Print Spool</smbconfoption>
1053 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/spool/samba</smbconfoption>
1054 <smbconfoption name="guest ok">Yes</smbconfoption>
1055 <smbconfoption name="printable">Yes</smbconfoption>
1056 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
1058 <smbconfsection name="[print$]"/>
1059 <smbconfoption name="comment">Printer Drivers</smbconfoption>
1060 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/lib/samba/drivers</smbconfoption>
1061 <smbconfoption name="admin users">root, Administrator</smbconfoption>
1062 <smbconfoption name="write list">root</smbconfoption>
1063 </smbconfblock>
1064 </example>
1065 </sect2>
1067 <sect2 id="adssdm">
1068 <title>Active Directory Domain with Samba Domain Member Server</title>
1070 <para>
1071 <indexterm><primary>Active Directory</primary><secondary>join</secondary></indexterm>
1072 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1073 <indexterm><primary>Domain Member</primary><secondary>server</secondary></indexterm>
1074 One of the much-sought-after features new to Samba-3 is the ability to join an Active Directory
1075 domain using Kerberos protocols. This makes it possible to operate an entire Windows network
1076 without the need to run NetBIOS over TCP/IP and permits more secure networking in general. An
1077 exhaustively complete discussion of the protocols is not possible in this book; perhaps a
1078 later book may explore the intricacies of the NetBIOS-less operation that Samba-3 can participate
1079 in. For now, we simply focus on how a Samba-3 server can be made a domain member server.
1080 </para>
1082 <para>
1083 <indexterm><primary>Active Directory</primary></indexterm>
1084 <indexterm><primary>LDAP</primary></indexterm>
1085 <indexterm><primary>Identity resolution</primary></indexterm>
1086 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1087 The diagram in <link linkend="ch9-adsdc"/> demonstrates how Samba-3 interfaces with
1088 Microsoft Active Directory components. It should be noted that if Microsoft Windows Services
1089 for UNIX (SFU) has been installed and correctly configured, it is possible to use client LDAP
1090 for identity resolution just as can be done with Samba-3 when using an LDAP passdb backend.
1091 The UNIX tool that you need for this, as in the case of LDAP on UNIX/Linux, is the PADL
1092 Software nss_ldap tool-set. Compared with use of winbind and Kerberos, the use of
1093 LDAP-based identity resolution is a little less secure. In view of the fact that this solution
1094 requires additional software to be installed on the Windows 200x ADS domain controllers,
1095 and that means more management overhead, it is likely that most Samba-3 ADS client sites
1096 may elect to use winbind.
1097 </para>
1099 <para>
1100 Do not attempt to use this procedure if you are not 100 percent certain that the build of Samba-3
1101 you are using has been compiled and linked with all the tools necessary for this to work.
1102 Given the importance of this step, you must first validate that the Samba-3 message block
1103 daemon (<command>smbd</command>) has the necessary features.
1104 </para>
1106 <para>
1107 The hypothetical domain you are using in this example assumes that the Abmas London office
1108 decided to take its own lead (some would say this is a typical behavior in a global
1109 corporate world; besides, a little divergence and conflict makes for an interesting life).
1110 The Windows Server 2003 ADS domain is called <constant>london.abmas.biz</constant> and the
1111 name of the server is <constant>W2K3S</constant>. In ADS realm terms, the domain controller
1112 is known as <constant>w2k3s.london.abmas.biz</constant>. In NetBIOS nomenclature, the
1113 domain name is <constant>LONDON</constant> and the server name is <constant>W2K3S</constant>.
1114 </para>
1116 <figure id="ch9-adsdc">
1117 <title>Active Directory Domain: Samba Member Server</title>
1118 <imagefile scale="60">chap9-ADSDC</imagefile>
1119 </figure>
1121 <procedure>
1122 <title>Joining a Samba Server as an ADS Domain Member</title>
1124 <step><para>
1125 <indexterm><primary>smbd</primary></indexterm>
1126 Before you try to use Samba-3, you want to know for certain that your executables have
1127 support for Kerberos and for LDAP. Execute the following to identify whether or
1128 not this build is perhaps suitable for use:
1129 <screen>
1130 &rootprompt; cd /usr/sbin
1131 &rootprompt; smbd -b | grep KRB
1132 HAVE_KRB5_H
1133 HAVE_ADDR_TYPE_IN_KRB5_ADDRESS
1134 HAVE_KRB5
1135 HAVE_KRB5_AUTH_CON_SETKEY
1136 HAVE_KRB5_GET_DEFAULT_IN_TKT_ETYPES
1137 HAVE_KRB5_GET_PW_SALT
1138 HAVE_KRB5_KEYBLOCK_KEYVALUE
1139 HAVE_KRB5_KEYTAB_ENTRY_KEYBLOCK
1140 HAVE_KRB5_MK_REQ_EXTENDED
1141 HAVE_KRB5_PRINCIPAL_GET_COMP_STRING
1142 HAVE_KRB5_SET_DEFAULT_IN_TKT_ETYPES
1143 HAVE_KRB5_STRING_TO_KEY
1144 HAVE_KRB5_STRING_TO_KEY_SALT
1145 HAVE_LIBKRB5
1146 </screen>
1147 This output was obtained on a SUSE Linux system and shows the output for
1148 Samba that has been compiled and linked with the Heimdal Kerberos libraries.
1149 The following is a typical output that will be found on a Red Hat Linux system that
1150 has been linked with the MIT Kerberos libraries:
1151 <screen>
1152 &rootprompt; cd /usr/sbin
1153 &rootprompt; smbd -b | grep KRB
1154 HAVE_KRB5_H
1155 HAVE_ADDRTYPE_IN_KRB5_ADDRESS
1156 HAVE_KRB5
1157 HAVE_KRB5_AUTH_CON_SETUSERUSERKEY
1158 HAVE_KRB5_ENCRYPT_DATA
1159 HAVE_KRB5_FREE_DATA_CONTENTS
1160 HAVE_KRB5_FREE_KTYPES
1161 HAVE_KRB5_GET_PERMITTED_ENCTYPES
1162 HAVE_KRB5_KEYTAB_ENTRY_KEY
1163 HAVE_KRB5_LOCATE_KDC
1164 HAVE_KRB5_MK_REQ_EXTENDED
1165 HAVE_KRB5_PRINCIPAL2SALT
1166 HAVE_KRB5_PRINC_COMPONENT
1167 HAVE_KRB5_SET_DEFAULT_TGS_KTYPES
1168 HAVE_KRB5_SET_REAL_TIME
1169 HAVE_KRB5_STRING_TO_KEY
1170 HAVE_KRB5_TKT_ENC_PART2
1171 HAVE_KRB5_USE_ENCTYPE
1172 HAVE_LIBGSSAPI_KRB5
1173 HAVE_LIBKRB5
1174 </screen>
1175 You can validate that Samba has been compiled and linked with LDAP support
1176 by executing:
1177 <screen>
1178 &rootprompt; smbd -b | grep LDAP
1179 massive:/usr/sbin # smbd -b | grep LDAP
1180 HAVE_LDAP_H
1181 HAVE_LDAP
1182 HAVE_LDAP_DOMAIN2HOSTLIST
1183 HAVE_LDAP_INIT
1184 HAVE_LDAP_INITIALIZE
1185 HAVE_LDAP_SET_REBIND_PROC
1186 HAVE_LIBLDAP
1187 LDAP_SET_REBIND_PROC_ARGS
1188 </screen>
1189 This does look promising; <command>smbd</command> has been built with Kerberos and LDAP
1190 support. You are relieved to know that it is safe to progress.
1191 </para></step>
1193 <step><para>
1194 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary><secondary>libraries</secondary></indexterm>
1195 <indexterm><primary>MIT Kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1196 <indexterm><primary>Heimdal Kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1197 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary><secondary>MIT</secondary></indexterm>
1198 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary><secondary>Heimdal</secondary></indexterm>
1199 <indexterm><primary>Red Hat Linux</primary></indexterm>
1200 <indexterm><primary>SUSE Linux</primary></indexterm>
1201 <indexterm><primary>SerNet</primary></indexterm>
1202 <indexterm><primary>validated</primary></indexterm>
1203 The next step is to identify which version of the Kerberos libraries have been used.
1204 In order to permit Samba-3 to interoperate with Windows 2003 Active Directory, it is
1205 essential that it has been linked with either MIT Kerberos version 1.3.1 or later,
1206 or that it has been linked with Heimdal Kerberos 0.6 plus specific patches. You may
1207 identify what version of the MIT Kerberos libraries are installed on your system by
1208 executing (on Red Hat Linux):
1209 <screen>
1210 &rootprompt; rpm -q krb5
1211 </screen>
1212 Or on SUSE Linux, execute:
1213 <screen>
1214 &rootprompt; rpm -q heimdal
1215 </screen>
1216 Please note that the RPMs provided by the Samba-Team are known to be working and have
1217 been validated. Red Hat Linux RPMs may be obtained from the Samba FTP sites. SUSE
1218 Linux RPMs may be obtained from <ulink url="ftp://ftp.sernet.de">Sernet</ulink> in
1219 Germany.
1220 </para>
1222 <para>
1223 From this point on, you are certain that the Samba-3 build you are using has the
1224 necessary capabilities. You can now configure Samba-3 and the NSS.
1225 </para></step>
1227 <step><para>
1228 Using you favorite editor, configure the &smb.conf; file that is located in the
1229 <filename>/etc/samba</filename> directory so that it has the contents shown
1230 in <link linkend="ch9-adssdm"/>.
1231 </para></step>
1233 <step><para>
1234 Edit or create the NSS control file so it has the contents shown in <link linkend="ch9-sdmnss"/>.
1235 </para></step>
1237 <step><para>
1238 <indexterm><primary>/etc/samba/secrets.tdb</primary></indexterm>
1239 Delete the file <filename>/etc/samba/secrets.tdb</filename> if it exists. Of course, you
1240 do keep a backup, don't you?
1241 </para></step>
1243 <step><para>
1244 Delete the tdb files that cache Samba information. You keep a backup of the old
1245 files, of course. You also remove all files to ensure that nothing can pollute your
1246 nice, new configuration. Execute the following (example is for SUSE Linux):
1247 <screen>
1248 &rootprompt; rm /var/lib/samba/*tdb
1249 </screen>
1250 </para></step>
1252 <step><para>
1253 <indexterm><primary>testparm</primary></indexterm>
1254 Validate your &smb.conf; file using <command>testparm</command> (as you have
1255 done previously). Correct all errors reported before proceeding. The command you
1256 execute is:
1257 <screen>
1258 &rootprompt; testparm -s | less
1259 </screen>
1260 Now that you are satisfied that your Samba server is ready to join the Windows
1261 ADS domain, let's move on.
1262 </para></step>
1264 <step><para>
1265 <indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>ads</secondary><tertiary>join</tertiary></indexterm>
1266 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1267 This is a good time to double-check everything and then execute the following
1268 command when everything you have done has checked out okay:
1269 <screen>
1270 &rootprompt; net ads join -UAdministrator%not24get
1271 Using short domain name -- LONDON
1272 Joined 'FRAN' to realm 'LONDON.ABMAS.BIZ'
1273 </screen>
1274 You have successfully made your Samba-3 server a member of the ADS domain
1275 using Kerberos protocols.
1276 </para>
1278 <para>
1279 <indexterm><primary>silent return</primary></indexterm>
1280 <indexterm><primary>failed join</primary></indexterm>
1281 In the event that you receive no output messages, a silent return means that the
1282 domain join failed. You should use <command>ethereal</command> to identify what
1283 may be failing. Common causes of a failed join include:
1285 <itemizedlist>
1286 <listitem><para>
1287 <indexterm><primary>name resolution</primary><secondary>Defective</secondary></indexterm>
1288 Defective or misconfigured DNS name resolution.
1289 </para></listitem>
1291 <listitem><para>
1292 <indexterm><primary>Restrictive security</primary></indexterm>
1293 Restrictive security settings on the Windows 200x ADS domain controller
1294 preventing needed communications protocols. You can check this by searching
1295 the Windows Server 200x Event Viewer.
1296 </para></listitem>
1298 <listitem><para>
1299 Incorrectly configured &smb.conf; file settings.
1300 </para></listitem>
1302 <listitem><para>
1303 Lack of support of necessary Kerberos protocols because the version of MIT
1304 Kerberos (or Heimdal) in use is not up to date enough to support the necessary
1305 functionality.
1306 </para></listitem>
1307 </itemizedlist>
1309 <indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>rpc</secondary><tertiary>join</tertiary></indexterm>
1310 <indexterm><primary>RPC</primary></indexterm>
1311 <indexterm><primary>mixed mode</primary></indexterm>
1312 In any case, never execute the <command>net rpc join</command> command in an attempt
1313 to join the Samba server to the domain, unless you wish not to use the Kerberos
1314 security protocols. Use of the older RPC-based domain join facility requires that
1315 Windows Server 200x ADS has been configured appropriately for mixed mode operation.
1316 </para></step>
1318 <step><para>
1319 <indexterm><primary>tdbdump</primary></indexterm>
1320 <indexterm><primary>/etc/samba/secrets.tdb</primary></indexterm>
1321 If the <command>tdbdump</command> is installed on your system (not essential),
1322 you can look inside the <filename>/etc/samba/secrets.tdb</filename> file. If
1323 you wish to do this, execute:
1324 <screen>
1325 &rootprompt; tdbdump secrets.tdb
1326 {
1327 key = "SECRETS/SID/LONDON"
1328 data = "\01\04\00\00\00\00\00\05\15\00\00\00\EBw\86\F1\ED\BD\
1329 F6{\5C6\E5W\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\
1330 00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\
1331 00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00"
1332 }
1333 {
1334 key = "SECRETS/MACHINE_PASSWORD/LONDON"
1335 data = "le3Q5FPnN5.ueC\00"
1336 }
1337 {
1338 key = "SECRETS/MACHINE_SEC_CHANNEL_TYPE/LONDON"
1339 data = "\02\00\00\00"
1340 }
1341 {
1342 key = "SECRETS/MACHINE_LAST_CHANGE_TIME/LONDON"
1343 data = "E\89\F6?"
1344 }
1345 </screen>
1346 This is given to demonstrate to the skeptics that this process truly does work.
1347 </para></step>
1349 <step><para>
1350 It is now time to start Samba in the usual way (as has been done many time before
1351 in this book).
1352 </para></step>
1354 <step><para>
1355 <indexterm><primary>wbinfo</primary></indexterm>
1356 This is a good time to verify that everything is working. First, check that
1357 winbind is able to obtain the list of users and groups from the ADS domain controller.
1358 Execute the following:
1359 <screen>
1360 &rootprompt; wbinfo -u
1361 LONDON+Administrator
1362 LONDON+Guest
1363 LONDON+SUPPORT_388945a0
1364 LONDON+krbtgt
1365 LONDON+jht
1366 </screen>
1367 Good, the list of users was obtained. Now do likewise for group accounts:
1368 <screen>
1369 &rootprompt; wbinfo -g
1370 LONDON+Domain Computers
1371 LONDON+Domain Controllers
1372 LONDON+Schema Admins
1373 LONDON+Enterprise Admins
1374 LONDON+Domain Admins
1375 LONDON+Domain Users
1376 LONDON+Domain Guests
1377 LONDON+Group Policy Creator Owners
1378 LONDON+DnsUpdateProxy
1379 </screen>
1380 Excellent. That worked also, as expected.
1381 </para></step>
1383 <step><para><indexterm>
1384 <primary>getent</primary>
1385 </indexterm>
1386 Now repeat this via NSS to validate that full identity resolution is
1387 functional as required. Execute:
1388 <screen>
1389 &rootprompt; getent passwd
1390 ...
1391 LONDON+Administrator:x:10000:10000:Administrator:
1392 /home/LONDON/administrator:/bin/bash
1393 LONDON+Guest:x:10001:10001:Guest:
1394 /home/LONDON/guest:/bin/bash
1395 LONDON+SUPPORT_388945a0:x:10002:10000:SUPPORT_388945a0:
1396 /home/LONDON/support_388945a0:/bin/bash
1397 LONDON+krbtgt:x:10003:10000:krbtgt:
1398 /home/LONDON/krbtgt:/bin/bash
1399 LONDON+jht:x:10004:10000:John H. Terpstra:
1400 /home/LONDON/jht:/bin/bash
1401 </screen>
1402 Okay, ADS user accounts are being resolved. Now you try group resolution:
1403 <screen>
1404 &rootprompt; getent group
1405 ...
1406 LONDON+Domain Computers:x:10002:
1407 LONDON+Domain Controllers:x:10003:
1408 LONDON+Schema Admins:x:10004:LONDON+Administrator
1409 LONDON+Enterprise Admins:x:10005:LONDON+Administrator
1410 LONDON+Domain Admins:x:10006:LONDON+jht,LONDON+Administrator
1411 LONDON+Domain Users:x:10000:
1412 LONDON+Domain Guests:x:10001:
1413 LONDON+Group Policy Creator Owners:x:10007:LONDON+Administrator
1414 LONDON+DnsUpdateProxy:x:10008:
1415 </screen>
1416 This is very pleasing. Everything works as expected.
1417 </para></step>
1419 <step><para>
1420 <indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>ads</secondary><tertiary>info</tertiary></indexterm>
1421 <indexterm><primary>Active Directory</primary><secondary>server</secondary></indexterm>
1422 <indexterm><primary>Kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1423 You may now perform final verification that communications between Samba-3 winbind and
1424 the Active Directory server is using Kerberos protocols. Execute the following:
1425 <screen>
1426 &rootprompt; net ads info
1427 LDAP server: 192.168.2.123
1428 LDAP server name: w2k3s
1429 Realm: LONDON.ABMAS.BIZ
1430 Bind Path: dc=LONDON,dc=ABMAS,dc=BIZ
1431 LDAP port: 389
1432 Server time: Sat, 03 Jan 2004 02:44:44 GMT
1433 KDC server: 192.168.2.123
1434 Server time offset: 2
1435 </screen>
1436 It should be noted that Kerberos protocols are time-clock critical. You should
1437 keep all server time clocks synchronized using the network time protocol (NTP).
1438 In any case, the output we obtained confirms that all systems are operational.
1439 </para></step>
1441 <step><para>
1442 <indexterm><primary>net</primary><secondary>ads</secondary><tertiary>status</tertiary></indexterm>
1443 There is one more action you elect to take, just because you are paranoid and disbelieving,
1444 so you execute the following command:
1445 <programlisting>
1446 &rootprompt; net ads status -UAdministrator%not24get
1447 objectClass: top
1448 objectClass: person
1449 objectClass: organizationalPerson
1450 objectClass: user
1451 objectClass: computer
1452 cn: fran
1453 distinguishedName: CN=fran,CN=Computers,DC=london,DC=abmas,DC=biz
1454 instanceType: 4
1455 whenCreated: 20040103092006.0Z
1456 whenChanged: 20040103092006.0Z
1457 uSNCreated: 28713
1458 uSNChanged: 28717
1459 name: fran
1460 objectGUID: 58f89519-c467-49b9-acb0-f099d73696e
1461 userAccountControl: 69632
1462 badPwdCount: 0
1463 codePage: 0
1464 countryCode: 0
1465 badPasswordTime: 0
1466 lastLogoff: 0
1467 lastLogon: 127175965783327936
1468 localPolicyFlags: 0
1469 pwdLastSet: 127175952062598496
1470 primaryGroupID: 515
1471 objectSid: S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1109
1472 accountExpires: 9223372036854775807
1473 logonCount: 13
1474 sAMAccountName: fran$
1475 sAMAccountType: 805306369
1476 operatingSystem: Samba
1477 operatingSystemVersion: 3.0.20-SUSE
1478 dNSHostName: fran
1479 userPrincipalName: HOST/fran@LONDON.ABMAS.BIZ
1480 servicePrincipalName: CIFS/fran.london.abmas.biz
1481 servicePrincipalName: CIFS/fran
1482 servicePrincipalName: HOST/fran.london.abmas.biz
1483 servicePrincipalName: HOST/fran
1484 objectCategory: CN=Computer,CN=Schema,CN=Configuration,
1485 DC=london,DC=abmas,DC=biz
1486 isCriticalSystemObject: FALSE
1487 -------------- Security Descriptor (revision: 1, type: 0x8c14)
1488 owner SID: S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-512
1489 group SID: S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513
1490 ------- (system) ACL (revision: 4, size: 120, number of ACEs: 2)
1491 ------- ACE (type: 0x07, flags: 0x5a, size: 0x38,
1492 mask: 0x20, object flags: 0x3)
1493 access SID: S-1-1-0
1494 access type: AUDIT OBJECT
1495 Permissions:
1496 [Write All Properties]
1497 ------- ACE (type: 0x07, flags: 0x5a, size: 0x38,
1498 mask: 0x20, object flags: 0x3)
1499 access SID: S-1-1-0
1500 access type: AUDIT OBJECT
1501 Permissions:
1502 [Write All Properties]
1503 ------- (user) ACL (revision: 4, size: 1944, number of ACEs: 40)
1504 ------- ACE (type: 0x00, flags: 0x00, size: 0x24, mask: 0xf01ff)
1505 access SID: S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-512
1506 access type: ALLOWED
1507 Permissions: [Full Control]
1508 ------- ACE (type: 0x00, flags: 0x00, size: 0x18, mask: 0xf01ff)
1509 access SID: S-1-5-32-548
1510 ...
1511 ------- ACE (type: 0x05, flags: 0x12, size: 0x38,
1512 mask: 0x10, object flags: 0x3)
1513 access SID: S-1-5-9
1514 access type: ALLOWED OBJECT
1515 Permissions:
1516 [Read All Properties]
1517 -------------- End Of Security Descriptor
1518 </programlisting>
1519 And now you have conclusive proof that your Samba-3 ADS domain member server
1520 called <constant>FRAN</constant> is able to communicate fully with the ADS
1521 domain controllers.
1522 </para></step>
1524 </procedure>
1527 <para>
1528 Your Samba-3 ADS domain member server is ready for use. During training sessions,
1529 you may be asked what is inside the <filename>winbindd_cache.tdb and winbindd_idmap.tdb</filename>
1530 files. Since curiosity just took hold of you, execute the following:
1531 <programlisting>
1532 &rootprompt; tdbdump /var/lib/samba/winbindd_idmap.tdb
1533 {
1534 key = "S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-501\00"
1535 data = "UID 10001\00"
1536 }
1537 {
1538 key = "UID 10005\00"
1539 data = "S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1111\00"
1540 }
1541 {
1542 key = "GID 10004\00"
1543 data = "S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-518\00"
1544 }
1545 {
1546 key = "S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-502\00"
1547 data = "UID 10003\00"
1548 }
1549 ...
1551 &rootprompt; tdbdump /var/lib/samba/winbindd_cache.tdb
1552 {
1553 key = "UL/LONDON"
1554 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00\06\00\00\00\0DAdministrator\0D
1555 Administrator-S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-500-
1556 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513\05Guest\05
1557 Guest-S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-501-
1558 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-514\10
1559 SUPPORT_388945a0\10SUPPORT_388945a0.
1560 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1001-
1561 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513\06krbtgt\06
1562 krbtgt-S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-502-
1563 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513\03jht\10
1564 John H. Terpstra.S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1110-
1565 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513"
1566 }
1567 {
1568 key = "GM/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-512"
1569 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00\02\00\00\00.
1570 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1110\03
1571 jht\01\00\00\00-S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-500\0D
1572 Administrator\01\00\00\00"
1573 }
1574 {
1575 key = "SN/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513"
1576 data = "\00\00\00\00xp\00\00\02\00\00\00\0CDomain Users"
1577 }
1578 {
1579 key = "GM/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-518"
1580 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00\01\00\00\00-
1581 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-500\0D
1582 Administrator\01\00\00\00"
1583 }
1584 {
1585 key = "SEQNUM/LONDON\00"
1586 data = "xp\00\00C\92\F6?"
1587 }
1588 {
1589 key = "U/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1110"
1590 data = "\00\00\00\00xp\00\00\03jht\10John H. Terpstra.
1591 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1110-
1592 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513"
1593 }
1594 {
1595 key = "NS/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-502"
1596 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00-
1597 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-502"
1598 }
1599 {
1600 key = "SN/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-1001"
1601 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00\01\00\00\00\10SUPPORT_388945a0"
1602 }
1603 {
1604 key = "SN/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-500"
1605 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00\01\00\00\00\0DAdministrator"
1606 }
1607 {
1608 key = "U/S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-502"
1609 data = "\00\00\00\00bp\00\00\06krbtgt\06krbtgt-
1610 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-502-
1611 S-1-5-21-4052121579-2079768045-1474639452-513"
1612 }
1613 ....
1614 </programlisting>
1615 Now all is revealed. Your curiosity, as well as that of your team, has been put at ease.
1616 May this server serve well all who happen upon it.
1617 </para>
1619 <example id="ch9-adssdm">
1620 <title>Samba Domain Member &smb.conf; File for Active Directory Membership</title>
1621 <smbconfblock>
1622 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
1623 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
1624 <smbconfoption name="unix charset">LOCALE</smbconfoption>
1625 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">LONDON</smbconfoption>
1626 <smbconfoption name="realm">LONDON.ABMAS.BIZ</smbconfoption>
1627 <smbconfoption name="server string">Samba 3.0.20</smbconfoption>
1628 <smbconfoption name="security">ADS</smbconfoption>
1629 <smbconfoption name="username map">/etc/samba/smbusers</smbconfoption>
1630 <smbconfoption name="log level">1</smbconfoption>
1631 <smbconfoption name="syslog">0</smbconfoption>
1632 <smbconfoption name="log file">/var/log/samba/%m</smbconfoption>
1633 <smbconfoption name="max log size">50</smbconfoption>
1634 <smbconfoption name="printcap name">CUPS</smbconfoption>
1635 <smbconfoption name="ldap ssl">no</smbconfoption>
1636 <smbconfoption name="idmap uid">10000-20000</smbconfoption>
1637 <smbconfoption name="idmap gid">10000-20000</smbconfoption>
1638 <smbconfoption name="template primary group">"Domain Users"</smbconfoption>
1639 <smbconfoption name="template shell">/bin/bash</smbconfoption>
1640 <smbconfoption name="winbind separator">+</smbconfoption>
1641 <smbconfoption name="printing">cups</smbconfoption>
1643 <smbconfsection name="[homes]"/>
1644 <smbconfoption name="comment">Home Directories</smbconfoption>
1645 <smbconfoption name="valid users">%S</smbconfoption>
1646 <smbconfoption name="read only">No</smbconfoption>
1647 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
1649 <smbconfsection name="[printers]"/>
1650 <smbconfoption name="comment">SMB Print Spool</smbconfoption>
1651 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/spool/samba</smbconfoption>
1652 <smbconfoption name="guest ok">Yes</smbconfoption>
1653 <smbconfoption name="printable">Yes</smbconfoption>
1654 <smbconfoption name="browseable">No</smbconfoption>
1656 <smbconfsection name="[print$]"/>
1657 <smbconfoption name="comment">Printer Drivers</smbconfoption>
1658 <smbconfoption name="path">/var/lib/samba/drivers</smbconfoption>
1659 <smbconfoption name="admin users">root, Administrator</smbconfoption>
1660 <smbconfoption name="write list">root</smbconfoption>
1661 </smbconfblock>
1662 </example>
1664 <sect3>
1665 <title>IDMAP_RID with Winbind</title>
1667 <para>
1668 <indexterm><primary>idmap_rid</primary></indexterm>
1669 <indexterm><primary>SID</primary></indexterm>
1670 <indexterm><primary>RID</primary></indexterm>
1671 <indexterm><primary>IDMAP</primary></indexterm>
1672 The <command>idmap_rid</command> facility is a new tool that, unlike native winbind, creates a
1673 predictable mapping of MS Windows SIDs to UNIX UIDs and GIDs. The key benefit of this method
1674 of implementing the Samba IDMAP facility is that it eliminates the need to store the IDMAP data
1675 in a central place. The downside is that it can be used only within a single ADS domain and
1676 is not compatible with trusted domain implementations.
1677 </para>
1679 <para>
1680 <indexterm><primary>SID</primary></indexterm>
1681 <indexterm><primary>allow trusted domains</primary></indexterm>
1682 <indexterm><primary>idmap uid</primary></indexterm>
1683 <indexterm><primary>idmap gid</primary></indexterm>
1684 This alternate method of SID to UID/GID mapping can be achieved with the idmap_rid
1685 plug-in. This plug-in uses the RID of the user SID to derive the UID and GID by adding the
1686 RID to a base value specified. This utility requires that the parameter
1687 <quote>allow trusted domains = No</quote> must be specified, as it is not compatible
1688 with multiple domain environments. The <parameter>idmap uid</parameter> and
1689 <parameter>idmap gid</parameter> ranges must be specified.
1690 </para>
1692 <para>
1693 <indexterm><primary>idmap_rid</primary></indexterm>
1694 <indexterm><primary>realm</primary></indexterm>
1695 The idmap_rid facility can be used both for NT4/Samba-style domains as well as with Active Directory.
1696 To use this with an NT4 domain, the <parameter>realm</parameter> is not used. Additionally the
1697 method used to join the domain uses the <constant>net rpc join</constant> process.
1698 </para>
1700 <para>
1701 An example &smb.conf; file for an ADS domain environment is shown in <link linkend="sbe-idmapridex"/>.
1702 </para>
1704 <example id="sbe-idmapridex">
1705 <title>Example &smb.conf; File Using <constant>idmap_rid</constant></title>
1706 <smbconfblock>
1707 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
1708 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
1709 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">KPAK</smbconfoption>
1710 <smbconfoption name="netbios name">BIGJOE</smbconfoption>
1711 <smbconfoption name="realm">CORP.KPAK.COM</smbconfoption>
1712 <smbconfoption name="server string">Office Server</smbconfoption>
1713 <smbconfoption name="security">ADS</smbconfoption>
1714 <smbconfoption name="allow trusted domains">No</smbconfoption>
1715 <smbconfoption name="idmap backend">idmap_rid:KPAK=500-100000000</smbconfoption>
1716 <smbconfoption name="idmap uid">500-100000000</smbconfoption>
1717 <smbconfoption name="idmap gid">500-100000000</smbconfoption>
1718 <smbconfoption name="template shell">/bin/bash</smbconfoption>
1719 <smbconfoption name="winbind use default domain">Yes</smbconfoption>
1720 <smbconfoption name="winbind enum users">No</smbconfoption>
1721 <smbconfoption name="winbind enum groups">No</smbconfoption>
1722 <smbconfoption name="winbind nested groups">Yes</smbconfoption>
1723 </smbconfblock>
1724 </example>
1726 <para>
1727 <indexterm><primary>large domain</primary></indexterm>
1728 <indexterm><primary>Active Directory</primary></indexterm>
1729 <indexterm><primary>response</primary></indexterm>
1730 <indexterm><primary>getent</primary></indexterm>
1731 In a large domain with many users, it is imperative to disable enumeration of users and groups.
1732 For example, at a site that has 22,000 users in Active Directory the winbind-based user and
1733 group resolution is unavailable for nearly 12 minutes following first start-up of
1734 <command>winbind</command>. Disabling of such enumeration results in instantaneous response.
1735 The disabling of user and group enumeration means that it will not be possible to list users
1736 or groups using the <command>getent passwd</command> and <command>getent group</command>
1737 commands. It will be possible to perform the lookup for individual users, as shown in the procedure
1738 below.
1739 </para>
1741 <para>
1742 <indexterm><primary>NSS</primary></indexterm>
1743 <indexterm><primary>/etc/nsswitch.conf</primary></indexterm>
1744 The use of this tool requires configuration of NSS as per the native use of winbind. Edit the
1745 <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> so it has the following parameters:
1746 <screen>
1747 ...
1748 passwd: files winbind
1749 shadow: files winbind
1750 group: files winbind
1751 ...
1752 hosts: files wins
1753 ...
1754 </screen>
1755 </para>
1757 <para>
1758 The following procedure can be used to utilize the idmap_rid facility:
1759 </para>
1761 <procedure>
1762 <step><para>
1763 Create or install and &smb.conf; file with the above configuration.
1764 </para></step>
1766 <step><para>
1767 Edit the <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> file as shown above.
1768 </para></step>
1770 <step><para>
1771 Execute:
1772 <screen>
1773 &rootprompt; net ads join -UAdministrator%password
1774 Using short domain name -- KPAK
1775 Joined 'BIGJOE' to realm 'CORP.KPAK.COM'
1776 </screen>
1777 </para>
1779 <para>
1780 <indexterm><primary>failed join</primary></indexterm>
1781 An invalid or failed join can be detected by executing:
1782 <screen>
1783 &rootprompt; net ads testjoin
1784 BIGJOE$@'s password:
1785 [2004/11/05 16:53:03, 0] utils/net_ads.c:ads_startup(186)
1786 ads_connect: No results returned
1787 Join to domain is not valid
1788 </screen>
1789 The specific error message may differ from the above because it depends on the type of failure that
1790 may have occurred. Increase the <parameter>log level</parameter> to 10, repeat the above test,
1791 and then examine the log files produced to identify the nature of the failure.
1792 </para></step>
1794 <step><para>
1795 Start the <command>nmbd</command>, <command>winbind,</command> and <command>smbd</command> daemons in the order shown.
1796 </para></step>
1798 <step><para>
1799 Validate the operation of this configuration by executing:
1800 <indexterm><primary></primary></indexterm>
1801 <screen>
1802 &rootprompt; getent passwd administrator
1803 administrator:x:1000:1013:Administrator:/home/BE/administrator:/bin/bash
1804 </screen>
1805 </para></step>
1806 </procedure>
1808 </sect3>
1810 <sect3>
1811 <title>IDMAP Storage in LDAP using Winbind</title>
1813 <para>
1814 <indexterm><primary>ADAM</primary></indexterm>
1815 <indexterm><primary>ADS</primary></indexterm>
1816 The storage of IDMAP information in LDAP can be used with both NT4/Samba-3-style domains as well as
1817 with ADS domains. OpenLDAP is a commonly used LDAP server for this purpose, although any standards-compliant
1818 LDAP server can be used. It is therefore possible to deploy this IDMAP configuration using
1819 the Sun iPlanet LDAP server, Novell eDirectory, Microsoft ADS plus ADAM, and so on.
1820 </para>
1822 <para>
1823 The example in <link linkend="sbeunxa"/> is for an ADS-style domain.
1824 </para>
1826 <example id="sbeunxa">
1827 <title>Typical ADS Style Domain &smb.conf; File</title>
1828 <smbconfblock>
1829 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
1830 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
1831 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">SNOWSHOW</smbconfoption>
1832 <smbconfoption name="netbios name">GOODELF</smbconfoption>
1833 <smbconfoption name="realm">SNOWSHOW.COM</smbconfoption>
1834 <smbconfoption name="server string">Samba Server</smbconfoption>
1835 <smbconfoption name="security">ADS</smbconfoption>
1836 <smbconfoption name="log level">1 ads:10 auth:10 sam:10 rpc:10</smbconfoption>
1837 <smbconfoption name="ldap admin dn">cn=Manager,dc=SNOWSHOW,dc=COM</smbconfoption>
1838 <smbconfoption name="ldap idmap suffix">ou=Idmap</smbconfoption>
1839 <smbconfoption name="ldap suffix">dc=SNOWSHOW,dc=COM</smbconfoption>
1840 <smbconfoption name="idmap backend">ldap:ldap://ldap.snowshow.com</smbconfoption>
1841 <smbconfoption name="idmap uid">150000-550000</smbconfoption>
1842 <smbconfoption name="idmap gid">150000-550000</smbconfoption>
1843 <smbconfoption name="template shell">/bin/bash</smbconfoption>
1844 <smbconfoption name="winbind use default domain">Yes</smbconfoption>
1845 </smbconfblock>
1846 </example>
1848 <para>
1849 <indexterm><primary>realm</primary></indexterm>
1850 In the case of an NT4 or Samba-3-style domain the <parameter>realm</parameter> is not used, and the
1851 command used to join the domain is <command>net rpc join</command>. The above example also demonstrates
1852 advanced error reporting techniques that are documented in the chapter called "Reporting Bugs" in
1853 <quote>The Official Samba-3 HOWTO and Reference Guide, Second Edition</quote> (TOSHARG2).
1854 </para>
1856 <para>
1857 <indexterm><primary>MIT kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1858 <indexterm><primary>Heimdal kerberos</primary></indexterm>
1859 <indexterm><primary>/etc/krb5.conf</primary></indexterm>
1860 Where MIT kerberos is installed (version 1.3.4 or later), edit the <filename>/etc/krb5.conf</filename>
1861 file so it has the following contents:
1862 <screen>
1863 [logging]
1864 default = FILE:/var/log/krb5libs.log
1865 kdc = FILE:/var/log/krb5kdc.log
1866 admin_server = FILE:/var/log/kadmind.log
1868 [libdefaults]
1869 default_realm = SNOWSHOW.COM
1870 dns_lookup_realm = false
1871 dns_lookup_kdc = true
1873 [appdefaults]
1874 pam = {
1875 debug = false
1876 ticket_lifetime = 36000
1877 renew_lifetime = 36000
1878 forwardable = true
1879 krb4_convert = false
1880 }
1881 </screen>
1882 </para>
1884 <para>
1885 Where Heimdal kerberos is installed, edit the <filename>/etc/krb5.conf</filename>
1886 file so it is either empty (i.e., no contents) or it has the following contents:
1887 <screen>
1888 [libdefaults]
1889 default_realm = SNOWSHOW.COM
1890 clockskew = 300
1892 [realms]
1893 SNOWSHOW.COM = {
1894 kdc = ADSDC.SHOWSHOW.COM
1895 }
1897 [domain_realm]
1898 .snowshow.com = SNOWSHOW.COM
1899 </screen>
1900 </para>
1902 <note><para>
1903 Samba cannot use the Heimdal libraries if there is no <filename>/etc/krb5.conf</filename> file.
1904 So long as there is an empty file, the Heimdal kerberos libraries will be usable. There is no
1905 need to specify any settings because Samba, using the Heimdal libraries, can figure this out automatically.
1906 </para></note>
1907 <para>
1908 Edit the NSS control file <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> so it has the following entries:
1909 <screen>
1910 ...
1911 passwd: files ldap
1912 shadow: files ldap
1913 group: files ldap
1914 ...
1915 hosts: files wins
1916 ...
1917 </screen>
1918 </para>
1920 <para>
1921 <indexterm><primary>PADL</primary></indexterm>
1922 <indexterm><primary>/etc/ldap.conf</primary></indexterm>
1923 You will need the <ulink url="http://www.padl.com">PADL</ulink> <command>nss_ldap</command>
1924 tool set for this solution. Configure the <filename>/etc/ldap.conf</filename> file so it has
1925 the information needed. The following is an example of a working file:
1926 <screen>
1927 host 192.168.2.1
1928 base dc=snowshow,dc=com
1929 binddn cn=Manager,dc=snowshow,dc=com
1930 bindpw not24get
1932 pam_password exop
1934 nss_base_passwd ou=People,dc=snowshow,dc=com?one
1935 nss_base_shadow ou=People,dc=snowshow,dc=com?one
1936 nss_base_group ou=Groups,dc=snowshow,dc=com?one
1937 ssl no
1938 </screen>
1939 </para>
1941 <para>
1942 The following procedure may be followed to affect a working configuration:
1943 </para>
1944 <procedure>
1945 <step><para>
1946 Configure the &smb.conf; file as shown above.
1947 </para></step>
1949 <step><para>
1950 Create the <filename>/etc/krb5.conf</filename> file following the indications above.
1951 </para></step>
1953 <step><para>
1954 Configure the <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> file as shown above.
1955 </para></step>
1957 <step><para>
1958 Download, build, and install the PADL nss_ldap tool set. Configure the
1959 <filename>/etc/ldap.conf</filename> file as shown above.
1960 </para></step>
1962 <step><para>
1963 Configure an LDAP server and initialize the directory with the top-level entries needed by IDMAP
1964 as shown in the following LDIF file:
1965 <screen>
1966 dn: dc=snowshow,dc=com
1967 objectClass: dcObject
1968 objectClass: organization
1969 dc: snowshow
1970 o: The Greatest Snow Show in Singapore.
1971 description: Posix and Samba LDAP Identity Database
1973 dn: cn=Manager,dc=snowshow,dc=com
1974 objectClass: organizationalRole
1975 cn: Manager
1976 description: Directory Manager
1978 dn: ou=Idmap,dc=snowshow,dc=com
1979 objectClass: organizationalUnit
1980 ou: idmap
1981 </screen>
1982 </para></step>
1984 <step><para>
1985 Execute the command to join the Samba domain member server to the ADS domain as shown here:
1986 <screen>
1987 &rootprompt; net ads testjoin
1988 Using short domain name -- SNOWSHOW
1989 Joined 'GOODELF' to realm 'SNOWSHOW.COM'
1990 </screen>
1991 </para></step>
1993 <step><para>
1994 Store the LDAP server access password in the Samba <filename>secrets.tdb</filename> file as follows:
1995 <screen>
1996 &rootprompt; smbpasswd -w not24get
1997 </screen>
1998 </para></step>
2000 <step><para>
2001 Start the <command>nmbd</command>, <command>winbind</command>, and <command>smbd</command> daemons in the order shown.
2002 </para></step>
2003 </procedure>
2006 <para>
2007 <indexterm><primary>diagnostic</primary></indexterm>
2008 Follow the diagnostic procedures shown earlier in this chapter to identify success or failure of the join.
2009 In many cases a failure is indicated by a silent return to the command prompt with no indication of the
2010 reason for failure.
2011 </para>
2013 </sect3>
2015 <sect3>
2016 <title>IDMAP and NSS Using LDAP from ADS with RFC2307bis Schema Extension</title>
2018 <para>
2019 <indexterm><primary>rfc2307bis</primary></indexterm>
2020 <indexterm><primary>schema</primary></indexterm>
2021 The use of this method is messy. The information provided in this section is for guidance only
2022 and is very definitely not complete. This method does work; it is used in a number of large sites
2023 and has an acceptable level of performance.
2024 </para>
2026 <para>
2027 An example &smb.conf; file is shown in <link linkend="sbewinbindex"/>.
2028 </para>
2030 <example id="sbewinbindex">
2031 <title>ADS Membership Using RFC2307bis Identity Resolution &smb.conf; File</title>
2032 <smbconfblock>
2033 <smbconfcomment>Global parameters</smbconfcomment>
2034 <smbconfsection name="[global]"/>
2035 <smbconfoption name="workgroup">BUBBAH</smbconfoption>
2036 <smbconfoption name="netbios name">MADMAX</smbconfoption>
2037 <smbconfoption name="realm">BUBBAH.COM</smbconfoption>
2038 <smbconfoption name="server string">Samba Server</smbconfoption>
2039 <smbconfoption name="security">ADS</smbconfoption>
2040 <smbconfoption name="idmap uid">150000-550000</smbconfoption>
2041 <smbconfoption name="idmap gid">150000-550000</smbconfoption>
2042 <smbconfoption name="template shell">/bin/bash</smbconfoption>
2043 <smbconfoption name="winbind use default domain">Yes</smbconfoption>
2044 <smbconfoption name="winbind trusted domains only">Yes</smbconfoption>
2045 <smbconfoption name="winbind nested groups">Yes</smbconfoption>
2046 </smbconfblock>
2047 </example>
2049 <para>
2050 <indexterm><primary>nss_ldap</primary></indexterm>
2051 The DMS must be joined to the domain using the usual procedure. Additionally, it is necessary
2052 to build and install the PADL nss_ldap tool set. Be sure to build this tool set with the
2053 following:
2054 <screen>
2055 ./configure --enable-rfc2307bis --enable-schema-mapping
2056 make install
2057 </screen>
2058 </para>
2060 <para>
2061 <indexterm><primary>/etc/nsswitch.conf</primary></indexterm>
2062 The following <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> file contents are required:
2063 <screen>
2064 ...
2065 passwd: files ldap
2066 shadow: files ldap
2067 group: files ldap
2068 ...
2069 hosts: files wins
2070 ...
2071 </screen>
2072 </para>
2074 <para>
2075 <indexterm><primary>/etc/ldap.conf</primary></indexterm>
2076 <indexterm><primary>nss_ldap</primary></indexterm>
2077 The <filename>/etc/ldap.conf</filename> file must be configured also. Refer to the PADL documentation
2078 and source code for nss_ldap instructions.
2079 </para>
2081 <para>
2082 The next step involves preparation on the ADS schema. This is briefly discussed in the remaining
2083 part of this chapter.
2084 </para>
2086 <sect4>
2087 <title>IDMAP, Active Directory, and MS Services for UNIX 3.5</title>
2089 <para>
2090 <indexterm><primary>SFU</primary></indexterm>
2091 The Microsoft Windows Service for UNIX version 3.5 is available for free
2092 <ulink url="http://www.microsoft.com/windows/sfu/">download</ulink>
2093 from the Microsoft Web site. You will need to download this tool and install it following
2094 Microsoft instructions.
2095 </para>
2097 </sect4>
2099 <sect4>
2100 <title>IDMAP, Active Directory, and AD4UNIX</title>
2102 <para>
2103 Instructions for obtaining and installing the AD4UNIX tool set can be found from the
2104 <ulink url="http://www.geekcomix.com/cgi-bin/classnotes/wiki.pl?LDAP01/An_Alternative_Approach">
2105 Geekcomix</ulink> Web site.
2106 </para>
2108 </sect4>
2110 </sect3>
2112 </sect2>
2114 <sect2>
2115 <title>UNIX/Linux Client Domain Member</title>
2117 <para><indexterm>
2118 <primary>user credentials</primary>
2119 </indexterm>
2120 So far this chapter has been mainly concerned with the provision of file and print
2121 services for domain member servers. However, an increasing number of UNIX/Linux
2122 workstations are being installed that do not act as file or print servers to anyone
2123 other than a single desktop user. The key demand for desktop systems is to be able
2124 to log onto any UNIX/Linux or Windows desktop using the same network user credentials.
2125 </para>
2127 <para><indexterm>
2128 <primary>Single Sign-On</primary>
2129 <see>SSO</see>
2130 </indexterm>
2131 The ability to use a common set of user credential across a variety of network systems
2132 is generally regarded as a single sign-on (SSO) solution. SSO systems are sold by a
2133 large number of vendors and include a range of technologies such as:
2134 </para>
2136 <itemizedlist>
2137 <listitem><para>
2138 Proxy sign-on
2139 </para></listitem>
2141 <listitem><para>
2142 Federated directory provisioning
2143 </para></listitem>
2145 <listitem><para>
2146 Metadirectory server solutions
2147 </para></listitem>
2149 <listitem><para>
2150 Replacement authentication systems
2151 </para></listitem>
2152 </itemizedlist>
2154 <para><indexterm>
2155 <primary>Identity management</primary>
2156 </indexterm>
2157 There are really four solutions that provide integrated authentication and
2158 user identity management facilities:
2159 </para>
2161 <itemizedlist>
2162 <listitem><para>
2163 Samba winbind (free). Samba-3.0.20 introduced a complete replacement for Winbind that now
2164 provides a greater level of scalability in large ADS environments.
2165 </para></listitem>
2167 <listitem><para>
2168 <ulink url="http://www.padl.com">PADL</ulink> PAM and LDAP tools (free).
2169 </para></listitem>
2171 <listitem><para>
2172 <ulink url="http://www.vintela.com">Vintela</ulink> Authentication Services (commercial).
2173 </para></listitem>
2175 <listitem><para>
2176 <ulink url="http://www.centrify.com">Centrify</ulink> DirectControl (commercial).
2177 Centrify's commercial product allows UNIX and Linux systems to use Active Directory
2178 security, directory and policy services. Enhancements include a centralized ID mapping that
2179 allows Samba, DirectControl and Active Directory to seamlessly work together.
2180 </para></listitem>
2181 </itemizedlist>
2183 <para>
2184 The following guidelines are pertinent to the deployment of winbind-based authentication
2185 and identity resolution with the express purpose of allowing users to log on to UNIX/Linux desktops
2186 using Windows network domain user credentials (username and password).
2187 </para>
2189 <para>
2190 You should note that it is possible to use LDAP-based PAM and NSS tools to permit distributed
2191 systems logons (SSO), providing user and group accounts are stored in an LDAP directory. This
2192 provides logon services for UNIX/Linux users, while Windows users obtain their sign-on
2193 support via Samba-3.
2194 </para>
2196 <para>
2197 <indexterm><primary>Windows Services for UNIX</primary><see>SUS</see></indexterm>
2198 On the other hand, if the authentication and identity resolution backend must be provided by
2199 a Windows NT4-style domain or from an Active Directory Domain that does not have the Microsoft
2200 Windows Services for UNIX installed, winbind is your best friend. Specific guidance for these
2201 situations now follows.
2202 </para>
2204 <para>
2205 <indexterm><primary>PAM</primary></indexterm>
2206 <indexterm><primary>Identity resolution</primary></indexterm>
2207 <indexterm><primary>NSS</primary></indexterm>
2208 To permit users to log on to a Linux system using Windows network credentials, you need to
2209 configure identity resolution (NSS) and PAM. This means that the basic steps include those
2210 outlined above with the addition of PAM configuration. Given that most workstations (desktop/client)
2211 usually do not need to provide file and print services to a group of users, the configuration
2212 of shares and printers is generally less important. Often this allows the share specifications
2213 to be entirely removed from the &smb.conf; file. That is obviously an administrator decision.
2214 </para>
2216 <sect3>
2217 <title>NT4 Domain Member</title>
2219 <para>
2220 The following steps provide a Linux system that users can log onto using
2221 Windows NT4 (or Samba-3) domain network credentials:
2222 </para>
2224 <procedure>
2225 <step><para>
2226 Follow the steps outlined in <link linkend="wdcsdm"/> and ensure that
2227 all validation tests function as shown.
2228 </para></step>
2230 <step><para>
2231 Identify what services users must log on to. On Red Hat Linux, if it is
2232 intended that the user shall be given access to all services, it may be
2233 most expeditious to simply configure the file
2234 <filename>/etc/pam.d/system-auth</filename>.
2235 </para></step>
2237 <step><para>
2238 Carefully make a backup copy of all PAM configuration files before you
2239 begin making changes. If you break the PAM configuration, please note
2240 that you may need to use an emergency boot process to recover your Linux
2241 system. It is possible to break the ability to log into the system if
2242 PAM files are incorrectly configured. The entire directory
2243 <filename>/etc/pam.d</filename> should be backed up to a safe location.
2244 </para></step>
2246 <step><para>
2247 If you require only console login support, edit the <filename>/etc/pam.d/login</filename>
2248 so it matches <link linkend="ch9-pamwnbdlogin"/>.
2249 </para></step>
2251 <step><para>
2252 To provide the ability to log onto the graphical desktop interface, you must edit
2253 the files <filename>gdm</filename> and <filename>xdm</filename> in the
2254 <filename>/etc/pam.d</filename> directory.
2255 </para></step>
2257 <step><para>
2258 Edit only one file at a time. Carefully validate its operation before attempting
2259 to reboot the machine.
2260 </para></step>
2261 </procedure>
2263 </sect3>
2265 <sect3>
2266 <title>ADS Domain Member</title>
2268 <para>
2269 This procedure should be followed to permit a Linux network client (workstation/desktop)
2270 to permit users to log on using Microsoft Active Directory-based user credentials.
2271 </para>
2273 <procedure>
2274 <step><para>
2275 Follow the steps outlined in <link linkend="adssdm"/> and ensure that
2276 all validation tests function as shown.
2277 </para></step>
2279 <step><para>
2280 Identify what services users must log on to. On Red Hat Linux, if it is
2281 intended that the user shall be given access to all services, it may be
2282 most expeditious to simply configure the file
2283 <filename>/etc/pam.d/system-auth</filename> as shown in <link linkend="ch9-rhsysauth"/>.
2284 </para></step>
2286 <step><para>
2287 Carefully make a backup copy of all PAM configuration files before you
2288 begin making changes. If you break the PAM configuration, please note
2289 that you may need to use an emergency boot process to recover your Linux
2290 system. It is possible to break the ability to log into the system if
2291 PAM files are incorrectly configured. The entire directory
2292 <filename>/etc/pam.d</filename> should be backed up to a safe location.
2293 </para></step>
2295 <step><para>
2296 If you require only console login support, edit the <filename>/etc/pam.d/login</filename>
2297 so it matches <link linkend="ch9-pamwnbdlogin"/>.
2298 </para></step>
2300 <step><para>
2301 To provide the ability to log onto the graphical desktop interface, you must edit
2302 the files <filename>gdm</filename> and <filename>xdm</filename> in the
2303 <filename>/etc/pam.d</filename> directory.
2304 </para></step>
2306 <step><para>
2307 Edit only one file at a time. Carefully validate its operation before attempting
2308 to reboot the machine.
2309 </para></step>
2310 </procedure>
2312 </sect3>
2314 <example id="ch9-pamwnbdlogin">
2315 <title>SUSE: PAM <filename>login</filename> Module Using Winbind</title>
2316 <screen>
2317 # /etc/pam.d/login
2319 #%PAM-1.0
2320 auth sufficient pam_unix2.so nullok
2321 auth sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2322 auth required pam_securetty.so
2323 auth required pam_nologin.so
2324 auth required pam_env.so
2325 auth required pam_mail.so
2326 account sufficient pam_unix2.so
2327 account sufficient pam_winbind.so user_first_pass use_authtok
2328 password required pam_pwcheck.so nullok
2329 password sufficient pam_unix2.so nullok use_first_pass use_authtok
2330 password sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2331 session sufficient pam_unix2.so none
2332 session sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2333 session required pam_limits.so
2334 </screen>
2335 </example>
2337 <example id="ch9-pamwbndxdm">
2338 <title>SUSE: PAM <filename>xdm</filename> Module Using Winbind</title>
2339 <screen>
2340 # /etc/pam.d/gdm (/etc/pam.d/xdm)
2342 #%PAM-1.0
2343 auth sufficient pam_unix2.so nullok
2344 auth sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2345 account sufficient pam_unix2.so
2346 account sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2347 password sufficient pam_unix2.so
2348 password sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2349 session sufficient pam_unix2.so
2350 session sufficient pam_winbind.so use_first_pass use_authtok
2351 session required pam_dev perm.so
2352 session required pam_resmgr.so
2353 </screen>
2354 </example>
2356 <example id="ch9-rhsysauth">
2357 <title>Red Hat 9: PAM System Authentication File: <filename>/etc/pam.d/system-auth</filename> Module Using Winbind</title>
2358 <screen>
2359 #%PAM-1.0
2360 auth required /lib/security/$ISA/pam_env.so
2361 auth sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_unix.so likeauth nullok
2362 auth sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_winbind.so use_first_pass
2363 auth required /lib/security/$ISA/pam_deny.so
2365 account required /lib/security/$ISA/pam_unix.so
2366 account sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_winbind.so use_first_pass
2368 password required /lib/security/$ISA/pam_cracklib.so retry=3 type=
2369 # Note: The above line is complete. There is nothing following the '='
2370 password sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_unix.so \
2371 nullok use_authtok md5 shadow
2372 password sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_winbind.so use_first_pass
2373 password required /lib/security/$ISA/pam_deny.so
2375 session required /lib/security/$ISA/pam_limits.so
2376 session sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_unix.so
2377 session sufficient /lib/security/$ISA/pam_winbind.so use_first_pass
2378 </screen>
2379 </example>
2381 </sect2>
2383 <sect2>
2384 <title>Key Points Learned</title>
2386 <para>
2387 The addition of UNIX/Linux Samba servers and clients is a common requirement. In this chapter, you
2388 learned how to integrate such servers so that the UID/GID mappings they use can be consistent
2389 across all domain member servers. You also discovered how to implement the ability to use Samba
2390 or Windows domain account credentials to log on to a UNIX/Linux client.
2391 </para>
2393 <para>
2394 The following are key points made in this chapter:
2395 </para>
2397 <itemizedlist>
2398 <listitem><para>
2399 Domain controllers are always authoritative for the domain.
2400 </para></listitem>
2402 <listitem><para>
2403 Domain members may have local accounts and must be able to resolve the identity of
2404 domain user accounts. Domain user account identity must map to a local UID/GID. That
2405 local UID/GID can be stored in LDAP. This way, it is possible to share the IDMAP data
2406 across all domain member machines.
2407 </para></listitem>
2409 <listitem><para>
2410 Resolution of user and group identities on domain member machines may be implemented
2411 using direct LDAP services or using winbind.
2412 </para></listitem>
2414 <listitem><para>
2415 On NSS/PAM enabled UNIX/Linux systems, NSS is responsible for identity management
2416 and PAM is responsible for authentication of logon credentials (username and password).
2417 </para></listitem>
2418 </itemizedlist>
2420 </sect2>
2422 </sect1>
2424 <sect1>
2425 <title>Questions and Answers</title>
2427 <para>
2428 The following questions were obtained from the mailing list and also from private discussions
2429 with Windows network administrators.
2430 </para>
2432 <qandaset defaultlabel="chap09qa" type="number">
2433 <qandaentry>
2434 <question>
2436 <para>
2437 We use NIS for all UNIX accounts. Why do we need winbind?
2438 </para>
2440 </question>
2441 <answer>
2443 <para>
2444 <indexterm><primary>NIS</primary></indexterm>
2445 <indexterm><primary>encrypted passwords</primary></indexterm>
2446 <indexterm><primary>smbpasswd</primary></indexterm>
2447 <indexterm><primary>tdbsam</primary></indexterm>
2448 <indexterm><primary>passdb backend</primary></indexterm>
2449 <indexterm><primary>Winbind</primary></indexterm>
2450 You can use NIS for your UNIX accounts. NIS does not store the Windows encrypted
2451 passwords that need to be stored in one of the acceptable passdb backends.
2452 Your choice of backend is limited to <parameter>smbpasswd</parameter> or
2453 <parameter>tdbsam</parameter>. Winbind is needed to handle the resolution of
2454 SIDs from trusted domains to local UID/GID values.
2455 </para>
2457 <para>
2458 <indexterm><primary>winbind trusted domains only</primary></indexterm>
2459 <indexterm><primary>getpwnam()</primary></indexterm>
2460 On a domain member server, you effectively map Windows domain users to local users
2461 that are in your NIS database by specifying the <parameter>winbind trusted domains
2462 only</parameter>. This causes user and group account lookups to be routed via
2463 the <command>getpwnam()</command> family of systems calls. On an NIS-enabled client,
2464 this pushes the resolution of users and groups out through NIS.
2465 </para>
2467 <para>
2468 As a general rule, it is always a good idea to run winbind on all Samba servers.
2469 </para>
2471 </answer>
2472 </qandaentry>
2474 <qandaentry>
2475 <question>
2477 <para>
2478 Our IT management people do not like LDAP but are looking at Microsoft Active Directory.
2479 Which is better?<indexterm>
2480 <primary>Active Directory</primary>
2481 </indexterm>
2482 </para>
2484 </question>
2485 <answer>
2487 <para><indexterm>
2488 <primary>LDAP</primary>
2489 <secondary>server</secondary>
2490 </indexterm><indexterm>
2491 <primary>Kerberos</primary>
2492 </indexterm><indexterm>
2493 <primary>schema</primary>
2494 </indexterm>
2495 Microsoft Active Directory is an LDAP server that is intricately tied to a Kerberos
2496 infrastructure. Most IT managers who object to LDAP do so because
2497 an LDAP server is most often supplied as a raw tool that needs to be configured and
2498 for which the administrator must create the schema, create the administration tools, and
2499 devise the backup and recovery facilities in a site-dependent manner. LDAP servers
2500 in general are seen as a high-energy, high-risk facility.
2501 </para>
2503 <para><indexterm>
2504 <primary>management</primary>
2505 </indexterm>
2506 Microsoft Active Directory by comparison is easy to install and configure and
2507 is supplied with all tools necessary to implement and manage the directory. For sites
2508 that lack a lot of technical competence, Active Directory is a good choice. For sites
2509 that have the technical competence to handle Active Directory well, LDAP is a good
2510 alternative. The real issue is, What type of solution does
2511 the site want? If management wants a choice to use an alternative, they may want to
2512 consider the options. On the other hand, if management just wants a solution that works,
2513 Microsoft Active Directory is a good solution.
2514 </para>
2516 </answer>
2517 </qandaentry>
2519 <qandaentry>
2520 <question>
2522 <para>
2523 We want to implement a Samba PDC, four Samba BDCs, and 10 Samba servers. Is it possible
2524 to use NIS in place of LDAP?
2525 </para>
2527 </question>
2528 <answer>
2530 <para><indexterm>
2531 <primary>NIS</primary>
2532 </indexterm><indexterm>
2533 <primary>LDAP</primary>
2534 </indexterm><indexterm>
2535 <primary>encrypted passwords</primary>
2536 </indexterm><indexterm>
2537 <primary>synchronized</primary>
2538 </indexterm><indexterm>
2539 <primary>secure account password</primary>
2540 </indexterm><indexterm>
2541 <primary>PDC</primary>
2542 </indexterm><indexterm>
2543 <primary>BDC</primary>
2544 </indexterm>
2545 Yes, it is possible to use NIS in place of LDAP, but there may be problems with keeping
2546 the Windows (SMB) encrypted passwords database correctly synchronized across the entire
2547 network. Workstations (Windows client machines) periodically change their domain
2548 membership secure account password. How can you keep changes that are on remote BDCs
2549 synchronized on the PDC?
2550 </para>
2552 <para><indexterm>
2553 <primary>centralized storage</primary>
2554 </indexterm><indexterm>
2555 <primary>management</primary>
2556 </indexterm><indexterm>
2557 <primary>network Identities</primary>
2558 </indexterm>
2559 LDAP is a more elegant solution because it permits centralized storage and management
2560 of all network identities (user, group, and machine accounts) together with all information
2561 Samba needs to provide to network clients and their users.
2562 </para>
2564 </answer>
2565 </qandaentry>
2567 <qandaentry>
2568 <question>
2570 <para>
2571 Are you suggesting that users should not log on to a domain member server? If so, why?
2572 </para>
2574 </question>
2575 <answer>
2577 <para><indexterm>
2578 <primary>security</primary>
2579 </indexterm><indexterm>
2580 <primary>data</primary>
2581 <secondary>integrity</secondary>
2582 </indexterm><indexterm>
2583 <primary>mapped drives</primary>
2584 </indexterm>
2585 Many UNIX administrators mock the model that the personal computer industry has adopted
2586 as normative since the early days of Novell NetWare. The old
2587 perception of the necessity to keep users off file and print servers was a result of
2588 fears concerning the security and integrity of data. It was a simple and generally
2589 effective measure to keep users away from servers, except through mapped drives.
2590 </para>
2592 <para><indexterm>
2593 <primary>user logins</primary>
2594 </indexterm><indexterm>
2595 <primary>risk</primary>
2596 </indexterm><indexterm>
2597 <primary>user errors</primary>
2598 </indexterm><indexterm>
2599 <primary>strategy</primary>
2600 </indexterm><indexterm>
2601 <primary>policy</primary>
2602 </indexterm>
2603 UNIX administrators are fully correct in asserting that UNIX servers and workstations
2604 are identical in terms of the software that is installed. They correctly assert that
2605 in a well-secured environment it is safe to store files on a system that has hundreds
2606 of users. But all network administrators must factor into the decision to allow or
2607 reject general user logins to a UNIX system that is principally a file and print
2608 server the risk to operations through simple user errors.
2609 Only then can one begin to appraise the best strategy and adopt a site-specific
2610 policy that best protects the needs of users and of the organization alike.
2611 </para>
2613 <para><indexterm>
2614 <primary>system level logins</primary>
2615 </indexterm>
2616 From experience, it is my recommendation to keep general system-level logins to a
2617 practical minimum and to eliminate them if possible. This should not be taken as a
2618 hard rule, though. The better question is, what works best for the site?
2619 </para>
2621 </answer>
2622 </qandaentry>
2624 <qandaentry>
2625 <question>
2627 <para><indexterm>
2628 <primary>trusted domains</primary>
2629 </indexterm><indexterm>
2630 <primary>domain</primary>
2631 <secondary>trusted</secondary>
2632 </indexterm><indexterm>
2633 <primary>winbind trusted domains only</primary>
2634 </indexterm><indexterm>
2635 <primary>domain members</primary>
2636 </indexterm>
2637 We want to ensure that only users from our own domain plus from trusted domains can use our
2638 Samba servers. In the &smb.conf; file on all servers, we have enabled the <parameter>winbind
2639 trusted domains only</parameter> parameter. We now find that users from trusted domains
2640 cannot access our servers, and users from Windows clients that are not domain members
2641 can also access our servers. Is this a Samba bug?
2642 </para>
2644 </question>
2645 <answer>
2647 <para><indexterm>
2648 <primary>distributed</primary>
2649 </indexterm><indexterm>
2650 <primary>NIS</primary>
2651 </indexterm><indexterm>
2652 <primary>rsync</primary>
2653 </indexterm><indexterm>
2654 <primary>LDAP</primary>
2655 </indexterm><indexterm>
2656 <primary>winbindd</primary>
2657 </indexterm><indexterm>
2658 <primary>/etc/passwd</primary>
2659 </indexterm>
2660 The manual page for this <parameter>winbind trusted domains only</parameter> parameter says,
2661 <quote>This parameter is designed to allow Samba servers that are members of a Samba-controlled
2662 domain to use UNIX accounts distributed vi NIS, rsync, or LDAP as the UIDs for winbindd users
2663 in the hosts primary domain. Therefore, the user <constant>SAMBA\user1</constant> would be
2664 mapped to the account <constant>user1</constant> in <filename>/etc/passwd</filename> instead
2665 of allocating a new UID for him or her.</quote> This clearly suggests that you are trying
2666 to use this parameter inappropriately.
2667 </para>
2669 <para><indexterm>
2670 <primary>valid users</primary>
2671 </indexterm>
2672 A far better solution is to use the <parameter>valid users</parameter> by specifying
2673 precisely the domain users and groups that should be permitted access to the shares. You could,
2674 for example, set the following parameters:
2675 <screen>
2676 [demoshare]
2677 path = /export/demodata
2678 valid users = @"Domain Users", @"OTHERDOMAIN\Domain Users"
2679 </screen>
2680 </para>
2683 </answer>
2684 </qandaentry>
2686 <qandaentry>
2687 <question>
2689 <para>
2690 What are the benefits of using LDAP for my domain member servers?
2691 </para>
2693 </question>
2694 <answer>
2696 <para><indexterm>
2697 <primary>LDAP</primary>
2698 </indexterm><indexterm>
2699 <primary>benefit</primary>
2700 </indexterm><indexterm>
2701 <primary>UID</primary>
2702 </indexterm><indexterm>
2703 <primary>GID</primary>
2704 </indexterm><indexterm>
2705 <primary>Domain Controllers</primary>
2706 </indexterm><indexterm>
2707 <primary>Domain Member servers</primary>
2708 </indexterm><indexterm>
2709 <primary>copy</primary>
2710 </indexterm><indexterm>
2711 <primary>replicate</primary>
2712 </indexterm><indexterm>
2713 <primary>identity</primary>
2714 </indexterm>
2715 The key benefit of using LDAP is that the UID of all users and the GID of all groups
2716 are globally consistent on domain controllers as well as on domain member servers.
2717 This means that it is possible to copy/replicate files across servers without
2718 loss of identity.
2719 </para>
2721 <para><indexterm>
2722 <primary>Identity resolution</primary>
2723 </indexterm><indexterm>
2724 <primary>winbind</primary>
2725 </indexterm><indexterm>
2726 <primary>IDMAP backend</primary>
2727 </indexterm><indexterm>
2728 <primary>LDAP</primary>
2729 </indexterm><indexterm>
2730 <primary>Domain Controllers</primary>
2731 </indexterm><indexterm>
2732 <primary>Domain Member</primary>
2733 <secondary>servers</secondary>
2734 </indexterm><indexterm>
2735 <primary>Posix</primary>
2736 </indexterm><indexterm>
2737 <primary>account information</primary>
2738 </indexterm>
2739 When use is made of account identity resolution via winbind, even when an IDMAP backend
2740 is stored in LDAP, the UID/GID on domain member servers is consistent, but differs
2741 from the ID that the user/group has on domain controllers. The winbind allocated UID/GID
2742 that is stored in LDAP (or locally) will be in the numeric range specified in the <parameter>
2743 idmap uid/gid</parameter> in the &smb.conf; file. On domain controllers, the UID/GID is
2744 that of the POSIX value assigned in the LDAP directory as part of the POSIX account information.
2745 </para>
2747 </answer>
2748 </qandaentry>
2750 <qandaentry>
2751 <question>
2753 <para>
2754 Is proper DNS operation necessary for Samba-3 plus LDAP? If so, what must I put into
2755 my DNS configuration?
2756 </para>
2758 </question>
2759 <answer>
2761 <para><indexterm>
2762 <primary>DNS</primary>
2763 <secondary>configuration</secondary>
2764 </indexterm><indexterm>
2765 <primary>DNS</primary>
2766 <secondary>lookup</secondary>
2767 </indexterm><indexterm>
2768 <primary>hosts</primary>
2769 </indexterm><indexterm>
2770 <primary>/etc/nsswitch.conf</primary>
2771 </indexterm><indexterm>
2772 <primary>NSS</primary>
2773 </indexterm><indexterm>
2774 <primary>/etc/hosts</primary>
2775 </indexterm><indexterm>
2776 <primary>WINS</primary>
2777 <secondary>lookup</secondary>
2778 </indexterm>
2779 Samba depends on correctly functioning resolution of hostnames to their IP address. Samba
2780 makes no direct DNS lookup calls, but rather redirects all name-to-address calls via the
2781 <command>getXXXbyXXX()</command> function calls. The configuration of the <constant>hosts</constant>
2782 entry in the NSS <filename>/etc/nsswitch.conf</filename> file determines how the underlying
2783 resolution process is implemented. If the <constant>hosts</constant> entry in your NSS
2784 control file says:
2785 <screen>
2786 hosts: files dns wins
2787 </screen>
2788 this means that a hostname lookup first tries the <filename>/etc/hosts</filename>.
2789 If this fails to resolve, it attempts a DNS lookup, and if that fails, it tries a
2790 WINS lookup.
2791 </para>
2793 <para><indexterm>
2794 <primary>NetBIOS</primary>
2795 </indexterm><indexterm>
2796 <primary>TCP/IP</primary>
2797 </indexterm><indexterm>
2798 <primary>name resolution</primary>
2799 </indexterm>
2800 The addition of the WINS-based name lookup makes sense only if NetBIOS over TCP/IP has
2801 been enabled on all Windows clients. Where NetBIOS over TCP/IP has been disabled, DNS
2802 is the preferred name resolution technology. This usually makes most sense when Samba
2803 is a client of an Active Directory domain, where NetBIOS use has been disabled. In this
2804 case, the Windows 200x autoregisters all locator records it needs with its own DNS
2805 server or servers.
2806 </para>
2808 </answer>
2809 </qandaentry>
2811 <qandaentry>
2812 <question>
2814 <para>
2815 Our Windows 2003 Server Active Directory domain runs with NetBIOS disabled. Can we
2816 use Samba-3 with that configuration?
2817 </para>
2819 </question>
2820 <answer>
2822 <para>
2823 Yes.
2824 </para>
2826 </answer>
2827 </qandaentry>
2829 <qandaentry>
2830 <question>
2832 <para><indexterm>
2833 <primary>net</primary>
2834 <secondary>ads</secondary>
2835 <tertiary>join</tertiary>
2836 </indexterm><indexterm>
2837 <primary>net</primary>
2838 <secondary>rpc</secondary>
2839 <tertiary>join</tertiary>
2840 </indexterm>
2841 When I tried to execute net ads join, I got no output. It did not work, so
2842 I think that it failed. I then executed net rpc join and that worked fine.
2843 That is okay, isn't it?
2844 </para>
2846 </question>
2847 <answer>
2849 <para><indexterm>
2850 <primary>Kerberos</primary>
2851 </indexterm><indexterm>
2852 <primary>authentication</primary>
2853 </indexterm>
2854 No. This is not okay. It means that your Samba-3 client has joined the ADS domain as
2855 a Windows NT4 client, and Samba-3 will not be using Kerberos-based authentication.
2856 </para>
2858 </answer>
2859 </qandaentry>
2861 </qandaset>
2863 </sect1>
2865 </chapter>