1 <!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC
"-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Transitional//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-transitional.dtd">
2 <!-- Copyright (c) 2000,2001,2002,2003,2004,2005,2006,2007 Josh Coalson -->
3 <!-- Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document -->
4 <!-- under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.1 -->
5 <!-- or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; -->
6 <!-- with no invariant sections. -->
7 <!-- A copy of the license can be found at http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html -->
10 <meta http-equiv=
"Content-Type" content=
"text/html; charset=ISO-8859-1" />
11 <meta name=
"author" content=
"Josh Coalson" />
12 <meta name=
"description" content=
"A free, open source codec for lossless audio compression and decompression" />
13 <meta name=
"keywords" content=
"free,lossless,audio,codec,encoder,decoder,compression,compressor,archival,archive,archiving,backup,music" />
14 <link rel=
"shortcut icon" type=
"image/x-icon" href=
"favicon.ico" />
15 <link rel=
"stylesheet" type=
"text/css" href=
"flac.css" />
16 <title>FLAC - comparison
</title>
22 <a href=
"http://flac.sourceforge.net/"><img src=
"images/logo130.gif" alt=
"FLAC Logo" align=
"middle" border=
"0" hspace=
"0" /></a>
25 <div class=
"above_nav"></div>
28 <a href=
"index.html">home
</a> |
29 <a href=
"faq.html">faq
</a> |
30 <a href=
"news.html">news
</a> |
31 <a href=
"download.html">download
</a> |
32 <a href=
"documentation.html">documentation
</a> |
33 <a href=
"comparison.html">comparison
</a> |
34 <a href=
"changelog.html">changelog
</a> |
35 <a href=
"links.html">links
</a> |
36 <a href=
"developers.html">developers
</a>
40 english
|
41 <a href=
"ru/comparison.html">russian
</a>
44 <div class=
"below_nav"></div>
47 <div class=
"box_title">
50 <div class=
"box_header"></div>
51 <div class=
"box_body">
53 <table width=
"100%" border=
"0" cellspacing=
"0" cellpadding=
"0" bgcolor=
"#EEEED4"><tr><td>
54 <table width=
"100%" border=
"0" align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#EEEED4"><!-- @@@@@@ border="1" ? -->
58 <td align=
"center" bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC" colspan=
"2">
59 <font size=
"+1"><b>Encode time
</b></font>
61 <td align=
"center" bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC" colspan=
"2">
62 <font size=
"+1"><b>Decode time
</b></font>
64 <td align=
"center" bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC" colspan=
"2">
65 <font size=
"+1"><b>Compression
</b></font>
69 <td align=
"left" bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
70 <font size=
"+1"><b>Codec
</b></font>
72 <td bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
73 <font size=
"+1">Total
</font>
75 <td bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
76 <font size=
"+1">CPU
</font>
78 <td bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
79 <font size=
"+1">Total
</font>
81 <td bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
82 <font size=
"+1">CPU
</font>
84 <td bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
85 <font size=
"+1">Size
</font>
87 <td bgcolor=
"#F4F4CC">
88 <font size=
"+1"><b>Ratio
</b></font>
91 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">La
0.3c
</td><td>7:
32.82</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">7:
22.32</td><td>7:
15.80</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">7:
09.32</td><td>20.77 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">53.12%
</td></tr>
92 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">Monkey's Audio
3.99 (insane)
</td><td>6:
32.30</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">6:
21.61</td><td>6:
49.12</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">6:
42.82</td><td>21.22 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">54.27%
</td></tr>
93 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">optimFROG
4.21 (mode
4 @
1x)
</td><td>16:
52.17</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">16:
41.48</td><td>16:
54.93</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">16:
45.25</td><td>21.24 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">54.33%
</td></tr>
94 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">optimFROG
4.21 (mode
3 @
4x)
</td><td>2:
55.93</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">2:
44.65</td><td>2:
59.07</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">2:
50.82</td><td>21.25 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">54.36%
</td></tr>
95 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">optimFROG
4.21 (mode
2 @
4x)
</td><td>1:
38.57</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">1:
26.58</td><td>1:
41.85</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">1:
32.93</td><td>21.33 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">54.55%
</td></tr>
96 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">optimFROG
4.21 (mode
1 @
4x)
</td><td>1:
14.99</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">1:
02.51</td><td>1:
17.80</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">1:
09.10</td><td>21.36 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">54.64%
</td></tr>
97 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Monkey's Audio
3.99 (extra high)
</td><td>1:
26.61</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">1:
16.07</td><td>1:
30.36</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">1:
21.44</td><td>21.40 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">54.75%
</td></tr>
98 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">Tak
1.01 (extra high max)
</td><td>3:
26.43</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">3:
17.09</td><td>0:
23.19</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
13.42</td><td>21.49 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">54.96%
</td></tr>
99 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Tak
1.01 (extra high)
</td><td>1:
15.74</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">1:
05.08</td><td>0:
23.06</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
14.16</td><td>21.52 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">55.04%
</td></tr>
100 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">Monkey's Audio
3.99 (high)
</td><td>0:
46.91</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
36.45</td><td>0:
49.98</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
41.16</td><td>21.66 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">55.40%
</td></tr>
101 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Tak
1.01 (normal)
</td><td>0:
35.39</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
24.39</td><td>0:
20.80</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
12.14</td><td>21.73 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">55.57%
</td></tr>
102 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">Monkey's Audio
3.99 (normal)
</td><td>0:
41.22</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
30.24</td><td>0:
42.70</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
34.05</td><td>21.76 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">55.65%
</td></tr>
103 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">optimFROG
4.21 (mode
0 @
4x)
</td><td>0:
53.02</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
40.30</td><td>0:
55.09</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
45.66</td><td>21.89 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">55.98%
</td></tr>
104 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">WavPack
4.41 (extra high -x)
</td><td>1:
22.52</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">1:
09.69</td><td>0:
33.63</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
23.76</td><td>22.04 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">56.37%
</td></tr>
105 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Monkey's Audio
3.99 (fast)
</td><td>0:
31.61</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
20.95</td><td>0:
34.93</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
26.09</td><td>22.13 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">56.60%
</td></tr>
106 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">WavPack
4.41 (high)
</td><td>0:
35.98</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
22.81</td><td>0:
29.07</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
18.33</td><td>22.34 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">57.14%
</td></tr>
107 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">WavPack
4.41 (normal -x)
</td><td>0:
45.15</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
31.71</td><td>0:
22.65</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
13.11</td><td>22.96 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">58.74%
</td></tr>
108 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">Tak
1.01 (turbo)
</td><td>0:
23.45</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
11.80</td><td>0:
18.30</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
09.09</td><td>23.06 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">58.97%
</td></tr>
109 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">FLAC
1.2.1 (-
8)
</td><td>1:
22.33</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">1:
11.76</td><td>0:
17.64</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
08.48</td><td>23.19 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">59.31%
</td></tr>
110 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">WavPack
4.41 (normal)
</td><td>0:
30.38</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
17.38</td><td>0:
23.35</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
14.22</td><td>23.26 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">59.50%
</td></tr>
111 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#FFFFFF"><td align=
"left">FLAC
1.2.1 (-
5, default)
</td><td>0:
31.32</td><td bgcolor=
"#FFFFFF">0:
20.10</td><td>0:
16.76</td><td bgcolor=
"#FFFFFF">0:
07.22</td><td>23.30 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#FFFFFF">59.61%
</td></tr>
112 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">Bonk
0.5</td><td>2:
39.84</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">2:
29.57</td><td>2:
09.43</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">2:
00.05</td><td>23.35 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">59.72%
</td></tr>
113 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Apple Lossless (iTunes
4.5)
</td><td>?
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">?
</td><td>?
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">?
</td><td>23.64 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">60.47%
</td></tr>
114 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">WavPack
4.41 (fast -x)
</td><td>0:
37.37</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
24.82</td><td>0:
19.97</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
10.54</td><td>23.81 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">60.91%
</td></tr>
115 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">WavPack
4.41 (fast)
</td><td>0:
28.08</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
14.53</td><td>0:
20.82</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
11.02</td><td>23.93 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">61.21%
</td></tr>
116 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">FLAC
1.2.1 (-
3)
</td><td>0:
23.76</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
11.00</td><td>0:
16.25</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
06.82</td><td>24.04 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">61.48%
</td></tr>
117 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Shorten
3.2a (-p8 -b2048)
</td><td>0:
38.45</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
26.71</td><td>0:
23.33</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
13.67</td><td>24.72 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">63.23%
</td></tr>
118 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">FLAC
1.2.1 (-
1)
</td><td>0:
20.60</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
08.53</td><td>0:
16.83</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">0:
07.17</td><td>24.78 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">63.40%
</td></tr>
119 <tr align=
"right"><td align=
"left">Shorten
3.2a (-p0 -b256, default)
</td><td>0:
31.14</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
19.24</td><td>0:
21.19</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">0:
11.28</td><td>25.34 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#F8F8E8">64.81%
</td></tr>
120 <tr align=
"right" bgcolor=
"#D4D4C0"><td align=
"left">RIFF WAVE
</td><td>1:
57.73</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4"></td><td>1:
57.73</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4"></td><td>39.09 MB
</td><td bgcolor=
"#E0E0D4">100.00%
</td></tr>
125 <b><a href=
"comparison_all_ratio.html">Complete summary table
</a></b><br />
127 <a href=
"comparison__chopin_prelude_24.html">Frederic Chopin Prelude No
.24 in d minor
</a><br />
128 <a href=
"comparison__dream_theater_600.html">Dream Theater
6:
00 </a><br />
129 <a href=
"comparison__eddie_warner_titus.html">Eddie Warner Titus
</a><br />
130 <a href=
"comparison__fanfare_de_l_eventail_de_jeanne.html">Maurice Ravel Fanfare from
"L'eventail de Jeanne" </a><br />
131 <a href=
"comparison__gloria_estefan_conga.html">Gloria Estefan Conga
</a><br />
132 Alanis Morissette Hand In My Pocket
<br />
133 <a href=
"comparison__l_sub_raga_sivapriya.html">L. Subramaniam Raga Sivapriya
</a><br />
134 <a href=
"comparison__laetatus_sum.html">The Benedictine Monks of Santo Domingo de Silos Laetatus Sum
</a><br />
135 <a href=
"comparison__mummified_in_barbed_wire.html">Cannibal Corpse Mummified In Barbed Wire
</a><br />
136 <a href=
"comparison__prokofiev_pcon3_3.html">Sergei Prokofiev Piano Concerto No
.3 (
3rd movement)
</a><br />
137 <a href=
"comparison__ravel_sq4_4.html">Maurice Ravel String Quartet (
4th movement)
</a><br />
138 <a href=
"comparison__scarlatti_k42.html">Domenico Scarlatti Sonata K
.42 (arr.Yepes for guitar)
</a><br />
139 <a href=
"comparison__tool_forty_six_and_2.html">Tool Forty-six
& 2 </a><br />
140 <a href=
"comparison__white_room.html">Cream White Room
</a><br />
142 </div> <!-- box_body -->
143 <div class=
"box_footer"></div>
147 <div class=
"copyright">
148 <!-- @@@ oh so hacky -->
152 Copyright (c)
2000,
2001,
2002,
2003,
2004,
2005,
2006,
2007 Josh Coalson
154 <td width=
"1%" align=
"right">
155 <a href=
"http://sourceforge.net"><img src=
"http://sflogo.sourceforge.net/sflogo.php?group_id=13478&type=1" width=
"88" height=
"31" border=
"0" alt=
"SourceForge.net Logo" /></a>
157 <td width=
"1%" align=
"right">
158 <a href=
"http://www.eff.org/cafe/"><img src=
"images/cafebug.gif" alt=
"CAFE Logo" border=
"0" /></a><br />
160 <td width=
"1%" align=
"right">
161 <a href=
"http://validator.w3.org/check?uri=referer"><img src=
"http://www.w3.org/Icons/valid-xhtml10" alt=
"Valid XHTML 1.0!" height=
"31" width=
"88" border=
"0" hspace=
"0" /></a>