1 <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC
"-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN"
2 "http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/loose.dtd">
9 <meta HTTP-EQUIV=
"Content-Type" CONTENT=
"text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
10 <title>Bob Dylan: Standing in the Doorway
</title>
11 <link rel=
"stylesheet" type=
"text/css" href=
"../css/general.css">
16 <h1 class=
"songtitle">Standing In The Doorway
</h1>
18 <p>Words and music by Bob Dylan
<br>
19 Released on
<em><a href=
"index.htm">Time Out Of Mind
</a> </em>(
1997)
<br>
20 Tabbed by Eyolf
Østrem
</p>
22 <p>(Click
<a HREF=
"doorway_chords.htm">here
</a> for a version without commentaries, only
25 <p>Capo
4th fret (just for the sake of convenience...). This seems like a song in the vein
26 of Simple twist of fate in open tuning, more or less the same beginning.
</p>
29 Chords (capo
4th) open tuning
</pre>
31 <pre>"C
" 032010 054000 (or
040000 or
000000)
34 C/g
332010 000000 (or
004000)
35 F
133211 555555 (or
020120)
36 Bb/f
113331 575655 (or
575675)
43 <pre>C C/b Am C/g bis
</pre>
46 I'm walkin' through the summer nights
48 the jukebox playing low
50 yesterday everything was goin' too fast
52 Today it's movin' too slow
</pre>
55 I got no place left to turn
57 I got nothin' left to burn
</pre>
60 Don't know if I saw you if I would kiss you or kill you
62 It probably wouldn't matter to you anyhow
64 You left me standing in the doorway cryin'
66 I got nothin' to go back to now.
</pre>
68 <pre>The light in this place is so bad
69 Makin' me sick in the head
70 All the laughter is just makin' me sad
71 The stars have turned cherry red
72 I'm strummin' on my gay guitar
74 The ghost of our old love has not gone away
75 Don't look it like it will anytime soon
76 You left me standin' in the doorway cryin'
77 Under the midnight moon.
</pre>
79 <pre>Maybe they'll get me and maybe they won't
80 But not tonight and it won't be here
81 There are things I could say, but I don't
82 I know the mercy of God must be near
83 I been ridin a midnight train
<a HREF=
"doorway.htm#1)">1)
84 </a> Got ice water in my veins
85 I would be crazy if I took you back
86 It would go up against every rule
87 You left me standin' in the doorway cryin'
88 Sufferin' like a fool.
</pre>
90 <pre>When the last rays of daylight go down
91 Buddy you'll roll no more
<a HREF=
"doorway.htm#2)">2)
92 </a>I can hear the church bells ringin' in the yard
93 I wonder who they're ringin' for
95 But my heart just won't give in
96 Last night I danced with a stranger
97 But she just reminded me you were the one
98 You left me standin' in the doorway cryin'
99 In the dark land of the sun.
</pre>
101 <pre>I eat when I'm hungry drink when I'm dry
<a HREF=
"doorway.htm#3)">3)
</a>
102 And live my life on the square
103 And even if the flesh falls off of my face
104 I know someone will be there to care
105 It always means so much
106 Even the softest touch
107 I see nothing to be gained by any explanation
108 There's no words that need to be said
109 You left me standin' in the doorway cryin'
110 Blues wrapped around my head.
</pre>
111 <a HREF=
"million_miles.htm">
113 <p>To next song (Million Miles)
</p></a>
117 <pre><a NAME=
"1)"></a>1) From Jesse Anderson:
118 I saw an album in a music store today by Doc Watson called
"Riding the
119 Midnight Train.
" I didn't buy it, but it probably refers to a lyric...
127 <pre><a NAME=
"2)"></a>2) From
<a HREF=
"http://www.bobdylanroots.com/">Manfred Helfert
</a>:
</pre>
129 <pre>Peter Stone Brown
<peterb@erols.com
> wrote:
131 >catherine yronwode wrote:
133 >> PHyatt1962 wrote:
135 > > From the Smithsonian
Folkways boxset:
137 > > "Buddy, Won't You Roll Down the Line
" by Uncle Dave Macon,
138 > > recorded in
1930
140 > > "...buddy, roll down line,
141 > > yonder comes my darling, coming down line...
"
143 >> Also, as has been mentioned here earlier, there is an oft-recorded white
144 >> Kentucky coal-miner's song
"Nine Pound Hammer
" (not to be completely
145 >> confused with, but somewhat similar to, the black railroad worker's song
146 >> "Take This Hmmer
")
148 >> Roll on, buddy, don't you roll so slow
149 >> How can i roll, when the wheels won't go?
152 >But
"Buddy Won't You Roll Down The Line
" is a completely different song
154 >"Nine Pound Hammer.
"
157 Maybe I can shed a little light on all these songs which became so
158 thoroughly mixed up in these previous posts (most of the factual info is
159 from Archie Green, Only A Miner, while most of the evaluations/conclusions
162 1) The
"black
" song, earliest recorded version (sung for noted folksong
163 collector Robert Winslow Gordon by William H. Stevens at Biltmore
– a
164 suburb of Asheville, NC, on Nov.
26,
1925) as
"Convict Song
" (about black
165 prisoners used as
"involuntary scabs
" in coal mines against orgainzed
166 labor
– presumably based on the Coal Creek troubles
1876-'
77):
168 CHORUS: O buddy, won't yer roll down the line,
169 Hop down, skip down,
170 Well, yonder comes my darlin'
171 Rollin' down the line.
173 IMO, this songs is also lyrically and structurally related to other prison
174 songs like
"Midnight Special.
"
176 Other variants by Watts and Wilson (as
"Chain Gang Special
"), Paramount
177 3019, Mar
1927 (black artists, song localized to Belmont, NC, area, about
178 convicts on a chain gang
"shoveling sand
"):
180 CHORUS: Hey, nigger won't you roll down the line,
181 Roll down the line.
182 Yonder comes my darling, roll down the line,
183 Keep a-rolling
– won't you roll down the line,
184 Roll on
– won't you roll down the line.
185 Yonder comes my darling, roll down the line,
187 Again, structural and lyrical similarities to the
"Midnight Special
" song
190 A rather abridged
"white
" version (references to forced labor basically left
191 out
– with the exception of references to a
"captain
" and the
"mouth of the
192 hole
" – , modeled slightly after
"Handsome Molly
"/
"Shady Grove
" song
193 families) was recorded by the Allen Brothers (Lee and Austin Allen) in Nov
194 1930 as
"Roll Down The Line
" (Victor
23551) and again in
1934 as
"Hey Buddy,
195 Won't You Roll Down The Line
" (Vocalion
02818).
197 CHORUS (
1931 version): Hey Buddy, won't you roll down the line,
198 Roll down the line.
199 Hey, yonder comes my darling, roll down the line,
200 Oh, roll down the line,
201 Roll down the line.
202 Hey, yonder comes my darling, roll down the line,
204 2) A related
"black/white
" song family
– clearly about the Coal Creek
206 one version
"Lone Rock Song
" collected by James Dombrowski from
"Uncle
207 Jesse
" James in
1937, who stated that he had learned the song as a young
208 miner from black convicts in Tracy City, Grundy County, TN
– far more
209 elaborate than the three previous variants (
11 stanzas) with clear and
210 explicit references to convict coal mining.
212 CHORUS: Buddy won't you roll down the mountain
213 Buddy won't you roll down the line,
214 Yonder come my darlin'
215 Comin' down the line.
217 The most widely circulated version: Uncle Dave Macon's version (with Sam
218 McGee),
"Buddy Won't You Roll Down The Line
", recorded Jul
25,
1928
219 (Brunswick
292) and reissued on Harry Smith's
"Anthology of American Folk
220 Music
"; also recorded by Pete Seeger (
"American Industrial Ballads
",
221 Folkways), The Gateway Singers (
"At the Hungry I
", Decca), The Kingston Trio
222 (
"String Along
", Capitol), and Hedy West (
"Serves 'Em Fine
", Fontana), to
225 Again explicit references to the Coal Creek labor struggles and the use of
226 convict miners
"against free labor stout
" – altogether a rather
"humorous
"
227 piece (consistent with Uncle Dave Macon's image) than the
"Lone Rock Song
".
229 CHORUS: Oh, Buddy, won't you roll down the line?
230 Buddy, won't you roll down the line?
231 Yonder comes my darling, coming down the line.
232 Buddy, won't you roll down the line?
233 Buddy, won't you roll down the line?
234 Yonder comes my darling, coming down the line.
236 Another possibly related variant was collected by John and Alan Lomax, from
237 unnamed black prisoners, in Memphis, TN, Jul
1933. The song itself is
238 basically the British broadside
"The Sailor Boy
" (aka
"Deep Blue Sea
",
"My
239 Willie's On the Dark Blue Sea
"), with a chorus basically identical to that
240 of the two previous versions and a rather
"incongruous
" reference to a
241 "captain
" who lost
90 of his
100 men (convicts?)
"when he got to
242 Nashville
" – basically the only reference tying this song in with the Coal
243 Creek labor struggles.
245 Further
"white
" variants (under the title
"Ole Humpy
"), clearly related to
246 or derived from the
"Lone Rock Song
" variant, were collected by Archie Green
249 3) The
"Nine Pound Hammer
" song family
– NOT related to the two previous
252 First variant in print: Robert Winslow Gordon, Adventure (
1924): one of six
253 fragments heard in southern railroad and other construction camps by Charles
254 Miller of Waycross, GA:
256 And it's roll on, buddy,
257 What makes you roll so slow?
258 Your buddy is almost broke
259 Down on the K.N.O.
261 Earliest commercial recording with the title
"Nine Pound Hammer
":
262 Al Hopkins and His Buckle Busters, May
1927 (Brunswick
177):
264 CHORUS: Nine pound hammer, just a little too heavy,
265 Baby, for my size, baby, for my size.
266 Roll on buddy, don't you roll so slow,
267 Baby, how can I roll when my wheel won't go?
269 According to Charles Bowman, an original member of the
"Buckle Busters
"
270 (interviewed by Archie Green,
1961), he learned parts of the song from black
271 railroad construction crews near Johnson City, TN, most likely between
1903
272 and
1905 when the C C
& O reached his community. The song itself is related
273 to the
"John Henry
" song family (
"Nine pound hammer killed John Henry
"), the
274 tune (according to Green) is related to that of
"Swannanoa Town
" (as
275 collected by Cecil Sharp in
1916).
277 Several other recordings by Grayson
& Whitter (Victor
40105,
1928), The
278 Monroe Brothers (
1936), and others.
280 Merle Travis' famous version (recorded Aug
8,
1946) is derived from the
281 Buckle Buster's variant via
"Texas Ruby
" Owens, with whom Merle had worked
282 before World War II on WLW, Cincinnati, OH.
284 He further confuses the matter, because he puts this original
"railroad
"
285 song into a coal mining setting (possibly because of
– subconscious --
286 recollections of
"another
" coal mining song of the #
1 or #
2 variety?). He
287 changed the chorus to read:
289 Roll on buddy, don't you roll so slow,
290 How can I roll when the wheels don't go?
291 Roll on buddy, pull a load of coal,
292 How can I pull when the wheels won't go?
294 and introduced the song:
296 "Up in East Kentucky around Harlan and Perry County, the coal miner sings a
297 little song called the 'Nine Pound Hammer.'...
299 Based on this intro, many people assumed Merle Travis being from
"around
300 Harlan and Hazard
" (he was from Ebenezer, KY, about
200 miles away), so that
301 he himself had to say the following about
"Nine Pound Hammer
" in later
304 "It's strange that folks would get mixed up about the old hammer song. I've
305 sung about Heaven all my life, and nobody ever thought I was from there.
"
307 Anyhow
– this has been my rather condensed analysis of the different song
308 families containing
"buddy
" and
"roll
" – I hope that nobody's more confused
314 Bob Dylan Musical Roots Site at
<a HREF=
"http://www.bobdylanroots.com/">http://www.yi.com/home/HelfertManfred/
315 </a>Doc Watson/Woody Guthrie Site at
<a HREF=
"http://www.geocities.com/Nashville/3448/">http://www.geocities.com/Nashville/
3448/
316 </a>American History in Song Site at
<a HREF=
"http://www.fortunecity.com/tinpan/parton/2/">http://www.fortunecity.com/tinpan/parton/
2/
</a></pre>
323 <p><a NAME=
"3)"></a></p>
325 <p>3) Finally I get the chance to add a quotation myself. The line
</p>
327 <p><em>I eat when I'm hungry, I drink when I'm dry
</em> <br>
329 could be
"stolen
" from Moonshine Blues (sung, i.a., on the second Gaslight
330 tape), where it goes:
</p>
332 <p><em>I eat when I'm hungry, I shine when I'm dry
</em> </p>
334 <p>Or, as
<a href=
"mailto:donaghcronin@unison.ie">donaghcronin@unison.ie
</a> points out,
335 "from a song by the clancy brothers which goes
</p>
338 <p><em>I'll eat when I'm hungry I'll drink when I'm dry
<br>
339 and if whisky doesn't kill me, I'll live till I die
</em></p>
342 <p>The Clancy Brothers were also the source of the tune for
<a href=
"../03_times/withgod.htm"><em>With God on our Side
</em></a>. The original song was
<em>The
343 patriot game
</em> written by dominic behan, brother of brendan.
"</p>